N
There are some really obvious reasons this is a deranged take (that doesn’t even line up with the critique Alon is making.) if you think about it for more than 12 seconds.
23,335,960 views
C
N
C
N
Replying to
@christosilvia
This requires setting some parameters. Do we have free wheeling control over service patterns? Both firms? Like it’s not a realistic description of how rail was being planned in the 1890s and early 1900s. Nationalization in Switzerland post dates that even. Not to mention UK and France.
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@nilo
Having two rail terminals in downtown NYC with no connection between them is exactly the failure mode you'd expect out of a system full of destructive competition and duplicative trackage
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@christosilvia
Given how actual turn of the century railroading worked, JP Morgan should have gotten Cassatt and Newman on his yacht and hammered out a deal for Pennsylvania to through run trains onto the GCT stub terminals. That or the New York City council should have insisted on it
12,200 views
N
Replying to
@christosilvia
Neither of these were conceived as primarily commuter terminals. What would through running have accomplished allowed Broadway limited riders to transfer to the east side without a cab? You’re conceiving of the project in terms that no rail engineers were thinking of at the time.
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@nilo
Through running isn't necessarily even just a commuter thing - Amtrak through running certainly isn't for commuters, it's for long distance trips which use the North River Tubes as the only rail crossing point south of Selkirk
12,200 views
N
Replying to
@christosilvia
If you conceive of it as a long distance trip route it’s really only for the Hudson valley to maybe Syracuse to points south.
12,200 views
N
Replying to
@nilo
This is why before engaging in this discussion answer the question of how much control is had is so important. The amount of USA gov control isn’t abnormally small for the time. bsky.app/profile/nilo...
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@nilo
Sure but the railroads had a lot of control. Unfortunately the Central's haughtiness and bad timing of already being far along with renovating GCT meant that NYC and Pannsey couldn't agree to a Union Station like major railroads in many cities were able to.
12,200 views
N
Replying to
@christosilvia
I think this is really underestimates how difficult the construction of such a complex would have been while under operation. Building Penn and GCT independently was far simpler than the project you’re proposing two competitors build and finance together.
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@nilo
There's a couple ways of slightly modifying the penn GCT setup to make the situation slightly less insane. The fact that there's not even a direct subway connection is a clear example of the downsides of free enterprise railroads (I'm including the subway here as that was private at the time)
12,200 views
N
Replying to
@christosilvia
The subway was planned by the government. But everyone was a free enterprise railroad. Government planning was at best done in cooperation with private firms
12,200 views
Replies
C
Replying to
@nilo
There's at a very minimum a lot of nuance to saying "the subway was planned by the government". The state issued a franchise. The IND existing explicitly to do destructive competition with the IRT and BMT is definitely evidence of this not being a happy system
12,200 views