J
I'm having the same reaction, and then: "If a large swathe of the population feels they are being denied avenues for meaning-making in their lives, it becomes everyone’s problem, because they will find a way to make their lives meaningful, and in the absence of water they will drink sand."
9,673,390 views
M
Replying to
@jthayer
There is a lot of freewheeling historicizing in this essay. I don’t know for example that men were ever “handed” the roles of “provider, protector, patriarch” and that this provided whatever vague idea of “meaning” the essay wants us to think men lack.
5,550 views
O
Replying to
@matttttttttb
Yep, it falls into the same trap that a lot of tradwife discourse does of accepting the Right’s framing of the past. History is compressed into a timeless, idealized before. What were your great grandfathers’ lives like? Were they kings of their own castle or sharecroppers/servants/factory workers?
5,550 views
Replies
P
Replying to
@ooksbooks
I can’t tell you my family history without exposing myself to likely murder because I’m very visible with my nature and that would unmask me. But I can tell you I know that history and so many people were robbed of that gift. History isn’t poetry. It’s a snuff film.
5,550 views
S
Replying to
@ooksbooks
A lot of my male forebears had *worse* lives because women were oppressed. My grandpa had to drop out of school around 15 and go to work at a steel mill because as a boy he was the only one in the family who could earn a living wage.
5,550 views