Post

86 replies
A
Nothing worse than a book having the movie poster cover. Anyone else actively avoid these editions?
24,174,580 views
11
Replies
F
Replying to @asisherright
YES! They're the absolute worst :(
31,100 views
H
Replying to @asisherright
I hate it!!!
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
Definitely
31,100 views
K
Replying to @asisherright
They're always so ugly. And when they go back to the original cover but its got NOW A MAJOR MOTION PICTURE printed on the front 😤
31,100 views
P
Replying to @asisherright
Yes! I loathe them!
31,100 views
A
Replying to @asisherright
Goddess yes. Even if I like the movie, I want a wall between them. I don't want the movie's aesthetic tilting my imagination anymore than it already does!
31,100 views
A
Replying to @asisherright
always
31,100 views
A
Replying to @asisherright
I cover them in stickers 🤫
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
As a kid they used to anger me and I'd turn them around to face the other way on the library shelf 🤣
31,100 views
E
Replying to @asisherright
Yep. Can't seem to get past that, even when I like the movie. It's just wrong somehow.
31,100 views
L
Replying to @asisherright
with my whole miyazussy
31,100 views
G
Replying to @asisherright
Always.
31,100 views
J
Replying to @asisherright
I wouldn’t say avoid but definitely more drawn to books with original covers
31,100 views
J
Replying to @asisherright
Oof, I definitely hate that. I mostly prefer later editions that have similar covers, so they look nicer when I line them up on the shelf, but those covers with the actors and all on them just look so unappealing to me.
31,100 views
D
Replying to @asisherright
Not as bad as the bland cover with the banner "check out the adaptation on HBO Max+"
31,100 views
C
Replying to @asisherright
Yes!!! The book covers are an art too. Just putting the actors from the movie takes the soul of the book away.
31,100 views
N
Replying to @asisherright
Especially LOTR
31,100 views
J
Replying to @asisherright
I really liked the witcher 3 as a game so I wanted to get into the books. When I looked on amazon, I found the edition with the netflix show actors as the cover... I immidiately looked for other editions 😅
31,100 views
J
Replying to @asisherright
I always avoid!
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
It depends. If I love the movie version I might seek those covers out
31,100 views
D
Replying to @asisherright
I actually really liked the Daisy Jones and the Six tv show cover 😅
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
they always look so cheap
31,100 views
K
Replying to @asisherright
Thought it was just me. Found it especially horrific with the Lord Of The Rings/Hobbit books.
31,100 views
K
Replying to @asisherright
I loathe them. When I read a book my brain decides what the characters look like, not some casting director. They are way off the mark more often than not.
31,100 views
G
Replying to @asisherright
They even changed the name of the book _Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep_ to _Blade Runner_. I have to admit, though, given how great the movie was, I wasn't too upset.
31,100 views
S
Replying to @asisherright
especially if it's just a generic live action version of the main character just standing there.
31,100 views
K
Replying to @asisherright
Sometimes I think about 'The Immortal Life of Henrietta Lacks', and how her cells were taken without her getting compensation or without her consent and then them re-releasing the book with Oprah on the cover after the film came out.
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
This is kinda why I missed the train on the Harry Potter series. Right when I was finally interested in checking it out, the books had been changed over to the movie art. I remember the original cover illustrations, I liked them. Hogwash
31,100 views
B
Replying to @asisherright
If anything it should be the other way around.
31,100 views
C
Replying to @asisherright
Definitely
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
::: waves hand wildly ::: ME ME ME!!!
31,100 views
A
Replying to @asisherright
Part of why I learned to book bind is so I can take these mass movie paperbacks and turn them into much better hardcovers.
31,100 views
2
Replying to @asisherright
Absolutely. I don’t even like checking them out from the library.
31,100 views
B
Replying to @asisherright
There is one thing I can think of that's worse. A video game adaptation based cover.
31,100 views
K
Replying to @asisherright
I don’t know why it gives me the ick so badly
31,100 views
C
Replying to @asisherright
It's even worse when your ebook or audiobook used to have the "proper" cover but (unless you keep a local copy) they retrospectively change it to the tie-in version. Just another argument for physical media.
31,100 views
P
Replying to @asisherright
I think it's fine if it gets more people into reading. That just might be the thing that gets someone into being an avid reader.
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
They do this with Graphic Novels too - replacing the original art that vibes with the art inside with a picture of an actor who doesn't necessarily look like any of the characters inside.
31,100 views
A
Replying to @asisherright
I won’t buy a book if it has the movie poster.
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
Forsooth!
31,100 views
D
Replying to @asisherright
When I find a book I want to read that has been adapted for any screen I first go to ABE.com, and find a used copy. Preferably in hardback. And I'm promoting an independent bookseller.
31,100 views
G
Replying to @asisherright
I cannot abide them. I will avoid a movie tie-cover at all costs.
31,100 views
C
Replying to @asisherright
I can think of worse things, but not many.
31,100 views
B
Replying to @asisherright
Agreed. Where can one find non-movie/TV series-labeled versions of books? Wanted to buy a book for a friend and the only option seems to be used copies...
31,100 views
D
Replying to @asisherright
I gotta admit that while I'm ready the Hugh Howey trilogy, every time he mentions Juliette, I see Rebecca Ferguson in my mind's eye.
31,100 views
I
Replying to @asisherright
For me it’s specifically the people. Having real people on my book covers really breaks my immersion.
31,100 views
S
Replying to @asisherright
Absolutely. Reminds me how bad the film of the book was
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
What’s bad is if you have a digital copy of the book or audiobook and the provider just decides to change the cover one day without your knowledge or consent. Can’t change it back either! (*cough*Wheel of Time*cough*)
31,100 views
A
Replying to @asisherright
Wanted to buy the books after the Netflix Witcher series came out, and damn was it hard to find a copy without the "Netflix" logo on them
31,100 views
G
Replying to @asisherright
I give this one a pass because it has Patrick Stewart on it (And because this is what my folks brought back from an old used book store when I asked for the oldest copy of Moby Dick they could find)
31,100 views
S
Replying to @asisherright
Everyone does. After working in a bookstore anyone who read it or were interested before the movie prefer the original version. After? Kind of a toss up.
31,100 views
D
Replying to @asisherright
Disagree. If it gets more people to pick up the book, what's so bad about that? It's like when someone said to Tom Wolfe, "Look what Hollywood did to your book," and he said they hadn't done anything to it. People could still read it.
31,100 views
B
Replying to @asisherright
Makes my blood run cold.
31,100 views
S
Replying to @asisherright
One exception to this rule (is it a rule?) that comes to mind is The Martian. Original book art: Closeup of generic astronaut guy in helmet. Movie edition art: Closeup of Matt Damon in helmet. It's 97% identical.
31,100 views
1
Replying to @asisherright
Worse, going to see the movie after reading the book years before they made the movie. "One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest" being a possible exception, original POV was Chief's but the film nailed the intent and, well, Jack.
31,100 views
G
Replying to @asisherright
It should be the other way round: the film poster should be a version of the book cover.
31,100 views
C
Replying to @asisherright
It's not a vibe.
31,100 views
C
Replying to @asisherright
Kills something inside me whenever I see it.
31,100 views
S
Replying to @asisherright
Eh, it's fine. Unless it's a series and then I need all the covers to match.
31,100 views
S
Replying to @asisherright
For me it depends on how good or bad the movie turned out
31,100 views
L
Replying to @asisherright
Totally!
31,100 views
O
Replying to @asisherright
The absolute worst of this type of thing is renaming. One of my favorites WAS ‘Bid Time Return’. Ever heard of it? Maybe you know it under it’s more well known renamed title (or the movie). ‘Somewhere In Time’.
31,100 views
M
Replying to @asisherright
I even ensure my digital copies keep their pre-movie covers. It’s more than mildly annoying.
31,100 views
O
Replying to @asisherright
And the ones with the sticker-effect non-stickers on them.
31,100 views
P
Replying to @asisherright
Yes! And it's worse when the book is part of a series, so you have the first book with the movie cover and the others with a completely different art scheme.
31,100 views
G
Replying to @asisherright
Hate them. Is one of the most annoying things ever. I don't mind the "now a motion picture" sticker too much.
31,100 views
S
Replying to @asisherright
the worst is those fucking "now a movie" stickers that were annoying even before they started *printing onto the cover*
31,100 views
I
Replying to @asisherright
Always.
31,100 views
E
Replying to @asisherright
Hated when they did this to the Witcher series, I don't need to see that atrocity outside of Netflix
31,100 views
C
Replying to @asisherright
Yes, and when the authors name is bigger than the book title.
31,100 views