L
Kim Leadbeater making extremely powerful speech opening the Assisted Dying debate. Perhaps consciously echoes language around abortion rights. Closes by saying: "The right to choose does not take away the right not to choose."
23,813,500 views
A
Replying to
@lewisgoodall
I know it's a complex issue but I'm yet to hear a logical argument against it. My MP is voting against - apparently in summary because she just feels a bit off about it. That's fine - don't do it, but I'm not sure I can vote for someone who denies individuals personal rights about their own care.
18,500 views
J
Replying to
@andyd66
I'm in favour of individuals having the right to die but I think there are some legit concerns raised about:people feeling a burden, choosing it through lack of high quality palliative care, difficulty in relatives knowing and being able to challenge / overturn a decision in court, scope broadening
18,500 views
A
Replying to
@jburnhams
Yes it has the potential to normalise assisted dying as a choice some have to give thought to for themselves however unwilling, because relatives and others will introduce it. One could say maybe they should give thought to it, but I don't think you can underestimate the distress that could cause.
18,500 views
J
Replying to
@awheatley24
Not just relatives, the bill allows doctors to raise it with patients as an option
18,500 views
A
Replying to
@jburnhams
Yes that is also true. When one thinks of the normalisation of DNARs when not always what the PT would want, then it gives cause for concern.
18,500 views
A
Replying to
@awheatley24
I'm enjoying this site already - nice to ask a question and be met with thoughtful answers, unlike a stream of blue tick bile and abuse on Twitter! Agree, the legislation needs due care. If we vote against because of these concerns don't we have to stop all abortions and DNRs by extension of logic?
18,500 views
A
Replying to
@andyd66
I don't think so necessarily because the characteristics of each is different. I don't think we should stop all DNRs despite my using that example but I am just pointing to something that has become so normalised that the locus of power has shifted. It looks like the bill has passed now anyway.
18,500 views
Replies
J
Replying to
@awheatley24
Yes, I think good the vote has passed and the bill can continue through subsequent stages where concerns can be addressed
18,500 views