A
i guess this just comes back to my problems with punk in general. it just sounds like high schoolers who haven't learned how to play their instruments well or write a compelling song yet
23,941,870 views
I
Replying to
@angelic
Part of the punk movement was the idea that anyone could be in a punk band. Certainly some prominent punks like Sid Vicious were more about attitude than chops, but most of the major punk acts were musically talented and were choosing to play simply as a statement.
46,150 views
I
Replying to
@isabellesogay
The first wave of punks also created post punk and new wave as they diversified their musical approaches. Wire went from punk to post punk in three albums. The Clash were one of the most musically adventurous bands in the western world by 1979. Johnny Rotten forms Public Image, Ltd.
46,150 views
I
Replying to
@isabellesogay
Talking Heads connect with Brian Eno, Siouxsie and the Banshees released a seminal goth album, Blondie releases the first song with rap in it to hit number one on the Billboard Hot 100. Punk is an ethos as much as a musical identity.
46,150 views
I
Replying to
@isabellesogay
Then you have groups like The Dead Kennedys that used the bludgeoning nature of their music as a way to grab people’s attention to get their message out. Are there some punks who can’t write or play? Yeah, that happens in a movement that says anyone can be a part of it. But it’s not only that.
46,150 views
I
Replying to
@isabellesogay
Punk encourages people who don’t feel they could break into music and once immersed in that world they have opportunities to learn and grow. Not everyone will but punk is a surprisingly expansive genre and focusing on the people who don’t play formally well is missing the forest for the trees.
46,150 views
Replies
I
Replying to
@isabellesogay
This is Wire, a first wave punk band, in 1978. The boundaries of punk are a lot more porous than most people realize.
46,150 views