R
Amid the discussion of citizens' assemblies and the assisted dying bill, some thoughts... CAs can be a v useful tool to understand what the public think on a complex issue. We know participants can get to grips with technical detail and good facilitation can ensure high quality deliberation.
24,694,360 views
R
Replying to
@rebeccamckee
FYI a citizens' assembly is a broadly representative group of around 50–150 members of the public, chosen, by lottery, to discuss and make recommendations on a specific policy question/ set of questions as part of the policy-making process. Similar models include citizens’ panels & citizens’ juries
5,200 views
R
Replying to
@rebeccamckee
The model works well when there's little agreement among policy makers on the direction something should take and indeed if they face opposition whichever way they go. E.g. reaching net zero targets but what to trade off? Legalising access to abortion but under what circumstances?
5,200 views
R
Replying to
@rebeccamckee
The process allows for evidence taking and scrutiny. Participants hear from experts (academic, practitioner or even those with lived experience) and question them and ask for further information. Evidence can also be published online for wider public engagement.
5,200 views
R
Replying to
@rebeccamckee
CAs are excellent for exploring trade offs and different considerations. Importantly, participants discuss all of the evidence & their own views with each other. It's an opportunity for deliberation and consideration of trade offs that is often missing from public discourse on difficult topics.
5,200 views
R
Replying to
@rebeccamckee
CAs are not a replacement for parliament or government decision making they are a tool for gathering evidence on what an informed, representative group of the public think on complex issue when they've had the time to take in evidence and discuss it.
5,200 views
R
Replying to
@rebeccamckee
The range of 'public opinion' on some topics is baffling / overwhelming for decision makers and % agreement / disagreement swings hugely based on the question, the poll, the timing with little consideration of the different circumstances that the policy might be implemented under
5,200 views
R
Replying to
@rebeccamckee
Given all this assisted dying is a good candidate for a citizens' assembly - the government of Jersey ran one on this topic in 2021 However, the current debate highlights that public engagement is too often an after thought in policy making and risks being seen as 'kicking the can down the road'
5,200 views
Replies
R
Replying to
@rebeccamckee
There needs to be much more consideration, earlier on, on how to engage the public in policy making (many tools available!). And on topics such as assisted dying it should be government led, with a clear process for how recommendations will be considered and used.
5,200 views