Post

17 replies
C
Thanks that's interesting ! I might be absolutely wrong, but I don't think these two pieces are completely compatible in how they represent trans womanhood though. The c4ss piece wants a thing the other one doesn't I think
13,246,510 views
8
J
Replying to @closdeph
I would defer to the authors (I might be misunderstanding them) - but I don't necessarily think so - in what way do you mean?
6,950 views
C
Replying to @jessothomson
Again I might be wrong, but it seems that Talia Bhatt's piece advocates for the existence of a sort of general transfem experience that somewhat transcends particular cultures, whereas the c4ss piece places a lot of emphasis on the travesti experience as a particular culturally contingent thing
6,950 views
C
Replying to @closdeph
So for example when we hear in the c4ss piece that trans women are sometimes hostile to sex work as a practice, there are two things to think, either their material conditions are such that such an hostility is justified, or "oh they have their brands of swerfs"; I would favor the second explanation
6,950 views
J
Replying to @closdeph
Part of my argument is that Jules reifies certain things as being the product of identity, rather than political struggle - I wanted to emphasize several key victories of the movement in Argentina, which was largely at the vanguard of trans rights until Milei destroyed it all
6,950 views
J
Replying to @julieofthespiri
As well as one thing I find a major stumble of the movement, which is an embrace of sex work abolitionism, which is something I do not agree with. I felt it was especially important to mention this as Jules has a very idealized vision - but there's things to learn from and things to critique
6,950 views
Replies
J
Replying to @julieofthespiri
And I guess a lot of my general thrust was that a focus on identitarian issues is second place to political organization
6,950 views