Post

81 replies
D
lmao
13,725,430 views
19
A
Replying to @downtownkitty
On the subject, I've noticed that OPs tend to say Kamala lost the base because of whatever the OP's pet issue is. What I haven't seen is evidence that traditional Dems like Black men in PA and 18-24yos in MI shifted toward Trump because of Liz Cheney.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @audreyii
the evidence is that appealing to Liz Cheney was just a waste of time but democratic leadership has been dreaming of the election cycle where the moderate republican wakes from their slumber and saves them from all those darned minorities in the coalition since 94, so they're always going to try it
29,350 views
A
Replying to @bryceyoungquist
Where is that evidence? I'm happy to see it and adjust my take. But all I've seen is "Dems didn't turn out like we hoped, and also Kamala campaigned with Liz Cheney." That's only correlative with no proof one caused the other.
29,350 views
A
Replying to @audreyii
And specifically, how campaigning with Liz broke the coalitions in PA, WI, and MI that won Biden the White House in 2020.
29,350 views
C
Replying to @audreyii
Also read that DNC failed to do enough turnout efforts in rural areas which is why we lost Georgia and NC. Georgia demographically has been shifting in a way that favors a dem victory (suburbs becoming more ethnically diverse), not that I believe in pandering to interest groups in the first place.
29,350 views
A
Replying to @contrasci
I'd've loved to have GA and NC, but if we're talking cold hard facts, what matters is the Blue Wall. Biden won it in 2020. Harris lost it in 2024. Something (or a series of somethings) changed in those states and that's the ballgame. It's the closest apples-to-apples comparison we're likely to find.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @audreyii
inflation went up, pandemic era social programs went away, and the democratic party's answer to people saying "we are suffering" was "shut the fuck up, do you want Trump to win." the genocide and Liz Cheney merely didn't help the cause, which made the party's commitment to them absolutely baffling
29,350 views
A
Replying to @bryceyoungquist
I have seen no evidence that the Dem Party's platform was "shut the fuck up." I saw consistent call for policies that made a real life difference. I also saw evidence of terminally-online people on social media saying stupid shit to drive up engagement provided to curated algorithmic feeds.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @audreyii
While I agree they continued to call for some decent policy, economically they absolutely told us everything was fine. They continually pointed to their arbitrary numbers to say the economy is doing great, while real people are struggling as much as we ever have. That’s pretty close to “stfu”.
29,350 views
M
Replying to @ballparkfranks7
It’s hard to argue, though, that the administration didn’t work pretty fucking hard to pass into law/enact the kinds of policies that would have mitigated the inevitable circumstances that flowed from a global pandemic.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @mrpothead
Sure, and if that’s the direction you want to view it (which I agree is at least a factual viewpoint), you then have to acknowledge that they needed to do a better job the last 4 years highlighting these things. This admin was too quiet about its successes, and too quiet about R’s obstructionism.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @ballparkfranks7
Look at the border bill, for example. They should have absolutely pounded the fact that Trump killed the bipartisan border bill just so he could run on it. How many commercials mentioned that? I don’t remember any, and I’m in PA… it seems negligent to not hit that nail over and over again.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @ballparkfranks7
But also, there was no real follow up on the railroad strikes. It looked bad when he seemed to initially squash that, but then he stuck with them and got them some of their demands… but they never highlighted it. They should have screamed it from a mountaintop. They have to message constantly.
29,350 views
A
Replying to @ballparkfranks7
Dems should have been hammering all admin, no question. I think it was a combo of a) Biden not being that sort of politician (sigh), and b) 2024 info enviro being actively hostile. How do you get railroad strikes viral on a TikTok algorithm curated to tradwife content? I'm not sure anyone knows yet.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @audreyii
Yeah great point. It’s going to be hard to break into the algorithms now that everything’s kind of set. R’s getting started early on had given them a real foundation among those spaces, and getting to people already bubbled up will be very difficult.
29,350 views
M
Replying to @ballparkfranks7
Don’t despair, man. The information environment is what it is. But if he really fucks things up, there’s only so much that propaganda can do to paper it over. Now, neither one of us want to live through this shit, that’s for sure. But nothing is set in stone.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @mrpothead
I think Trump thrives as the attacker (narratively speaking). He has to be on offense. When he’s President, he’s in a defensive position, and I do think it will be easier to break through… but they have to get to building a non-traditional outreach ecosystem, and they need to start immediately.
29,350 views
A
Replying to @ballparkfranks7
And it's not as easy as just duplicating what MAGA has done, because the Democratic party is a coalition, while the GOP is a homogenous white nationalist party w/a handful of "pick me" hangers on that think the leopards won't eat their faces. Coalition parties are inherently hostile to groupthink.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @audreyii
Yeah fantastic point!
29,350 views
A
Replying to @ballparkfranks7
There's also the elephant in the room that none of us really want to focus on, because it's *so* disheartening. Maybe it wasn't the message OR the medium. Maybe Kamala ran as perfect a campaign as she could and eked out every vote it was possible to win. Maybe America just will not elect a woman.
29,350 views
B
Replying to @audreyii
I can give you one anecdotal example. My mom refuses to vote for a woman. She said the only woman she’d ever vote for is my sister. I’ve said before, but my mom is certainly not unique in any way. There are no doubt millions of women, let alone men, that are no different. People truly are ignorant.
29,350 views
M
Replying to @ballparkfranks7
if we allow ourselves to become prisoner to this notion,it will affect everything that we do as a party going forward. So, maybe there are efforts that we should undertake to help you know continue to eat away, but I think as a party, taking a woman off the table as a possible candidate is a mistake
29,350 views
A
Replying to @mrpothead
I don't *disagree*, but it's impossible to ignore that there were three consecutive elections against the same person, all candidates chasing the same coalitions, and, well... one of these things is not like the other. And the consequences have been unspeakable.
29,350 views
Replies
M
Replying to @audreyii
I also think trump, and this particular moment, are sui generis.
29,350 views