N
There are some really obvious reasons this is a deranged take (that doesn’t even line up with the critique Alon is making.) if you think about it for more than 12 seconds.
23,335,960 views
C
N
C
N
Replying to
@christosilvia
This requires setting some parameters. Do we have free wheeling control over service patterns? Both firms? Like it’s not a realistic description of how rail was being planned in the 1890s and early 1900s. Nationalization in Switzerland post dates that even. Not to mention UK and France.
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@nilo
Having two rail terminals in downtown NYC with no connection between them is exactly the failure mode you'd expect out of a system full of destructive competition and duplicative trackage
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@christosilvia
Given how actual turn of the century railroading worked, JP Morgan should have gotten Cassatt and Newman on his yacht and hammered out a deal for Pennsylvania to through run trains onto the GCT stub terminals. That or the New York City council should have insisted on it
12,200 views
N
Replying to
@christosilvia
Neither of these were conceived as primarily commuter terminals. What would through running have accomplished allowed Broadway limited riders to transfer to the east side without a cab? You’re conceiving of the project in terms that no rail engineers were thinking of at the time.
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@nilo
Through running isn't necessarily even just a commuter thing - Amtrak through running certainly isn't for commuters, it's for long distance trips which use the North River Tubes as the only rail crossing point south of Selkirk
12,200 views
N
Replying to
@christosilvia
If you conceive of it as a long distance trip route it’s really only for the Hudson valley to maybe Syracuse to points south.
12,200 views
C
Replying to
@nilo
So the original Pennsylvania was considering the Penn station mega project as giving it connections to knit the Pennsylvania, LIRR, and NYNE&H systems together into something which could really rival the New York Central. I don't know how much actual through running happened at first though
12,200 views
Replies
C
Replying to
@christosilvia
Pennsey definitely thought of Penn Station as a terminal for long distance trains first, and everything else second. It didn't turn out this way!
12,200 views