Post

12 replies
A
A swathe of security minded folks in Tr view Israel, now, as an existential threat, which requires the further marginalization of the PKK, so as to prevent a security vulnerability from which the Israelis could undermine Turkish security. This is partly cynical.
7,756,360 views
7
A
Replying to @aaronstein1
AKP/MHP want to win DEM support for a new constitution and see Ocalan as a pathway to do that, which when combined with mass arrests and the removal of elected mayors, could break the PKK's civilian movement in TR, thereby winning support for as yet unnamed concessions
5,200 views
A
Replying to @aaronstein1
This was premised, in part, on the need to maintain calm in Syria, so as to work through Russia to ensure stability, ie no new refugee flows, and to then concurrently continue to hit PKK targets in Iraq/Syria so weaken the group further after the "hendek war" in the SE
5,200 views
A
Replying to @aaronstein1
TR does not control HTS, but of course has the group penetrated, and so Im skeptical that Ankara is pulling the strings on this offensive in Syria. Very skeptical. It risks Russian bombardment, leading to more refugees heading north. A more stable Syria allows for Tr to continue to deport migrants
5,200 views
A
Replying to @aaronstein1
The SNA is different, of course, but they are, of course, a secondary actor to what is happening. The PKK/YPG in Syria, of course, are Tr's primary security threat in the country now. And reports of HTS-SDF modus vivendi around Aleppo (which is what we saw in 2012-2105) will not sit well in Ankara
5,200 views
A
Replying to @aaronstein1
The flash points will be Manbij, because of course it will be Manbij, and extending out to Tel Rifaat. In some ways we've gone back in time. TR can exert considerable leverage in Syria. It is not omnipotent. Events are moving fast. They'll want to talk to Russia. TR will be weighing military moves
5,200 views
A
Replying to @aaronstein1
SDF will want defensive lines around Manbij, heightening Turkish anxiety. But this will come back to domestic considerations and TR will have to consider how a SDF in a new more chaotic Syria could exacerbate its security concerns -- and how those security concerns interact w/ domestic politics
5,200 views
Replies
A
Replying to @aaronstein1
And those domestic considerations will be overlaid with extreme paranoia about Israel -- like extreme -- and the concurrent weakening of Hezb and Assad by the IDF that, in some ways, helped this along (the other is RU invaded UA), could lead to some wild takes on what is happening
5,200 views