Post

137 replies
B
There is something at the heart of this story that doesn’t add up, legally speaking. Quick fraud lecture for y’all. 🧵
22,088,110 views
3
Replies
B
Replying to @barristersecret
Fraud by false representation requires the dishonest making of a false statement, intending to make a gain for oneself or another, or a loss to another. (Section 2 of the Fraud Act 2006)
48,950 views
E
Replying to @barristersecret
Interesting as always.
48,950 views
M
Replying to @barristersecret
It is striking that the account of the events should not have even lead to a charge, let alone a conviction if the facts were accurately reported by Haigh. There must have been evidence of intent when she reported the theft to the Police rather than just a mistake in the heat of the moment.
48,950 views
D
Replying to @barristersecret
The Guardian tells a rather different story to the one that first emerged, which makes a little more sense. www.theguardian.com/politics/202...
48,950 views
A
Replying to @barristersecret
I was waiting for a legal professional to spread a little more light on this. It also seems like a comparatively ridiculous thing either way to suddenly oust yourself and resign for. Shady shiftings indeed. Thank you.
48,950 views
B
Replying to @barristersecret
Well there have been some unnamed “ex colleagues” who have come out of the woodwork claiming she did it to obtain a new phone…..resigning when she did was probably the right thing to do to stop the feeding frenzy
48,950 views
J
Replying to @barristersecret
#Starmer was also concerned that Haigh did not declare the conviction to the Cabinet Office’s propriety and ethics team in line with the ministerial code, which requires *government ministers to behave with transparency and honesty..*🤨 Ya, don't say!😳🙄🤥
48,950 views
P
Replying to @barristersecret
She was given a discharge. Does that not tell you all you need to know? Lots of criminal cases have anomalies, but surely for the guilty, it's the sentencing that matters most. I don't think there is anything of any importance to be revealed.
48,950 views
R
Replying to @barristersecret
Thanks for explaining - I thought the story seemed smelly. I read it and put myself in the same position and it felt like and honest mistake - so why would she be convicted. Surely when she turned on the phone she would just apologize and say she made a mistake
48,950 views
L
Replying to @barristersecret
Glad I found you on here
48,950 views
M
Replying to @barristersecret
Don't know how many offences I've dealt with where victims struggle to recall what exactly was taken (ie, it's a big bag of stuff). Where something seems gone but they find it later, I've known them ring back to say "oh, I found the phone." "OK - we'll cross it off the list of things." - the end.
48,950 views
L
Replying to @barristersecret
📌
48,950 views
M
Replying to @barristersecret
Yeah... Apparently she did it in a completely "not done it" kind of way.
48,950 views
E
Replying to @barristersecret
Thanks SB, this has been very useful. I guess we wait for the rest of it to surface now.
48,950 views
C
Replying to @barristersecret
What IS clear would seem to be a rather opaque episode where facile reasons & answers have been given for something more serious. The rapid resignation underlines this.
48,950 views
J
Replying to @barristersecret
Wasn't this when she was literally about to try and become an MP. I wondered if her sole goal was getting the thing out of the way asap.
48,950 views
C
Replying to @barristersecret
Gut feel is that she’s been less than honest, which I also suspect is why Starmers rather concise response to her resignation letter. I think he’s decided she’s more trouble than she’s worth
48,950 views
L
Replying to @barristersecret
Didn't she plead guilty to making a false report under the criminal law act?
48,950 views
S
Replying to @barristersecret
Glad someone with a discerning eye has added a little expertise to this matter because frankly the whole matter seems a little odd. Maybe we’re just not used to people not resigning or have Labour just got ahead of a bigger story?
48,950 views
C
Replying to @barristersecret
Behind a paywall and I won’t fund this media company sorry. Call me naive
48,950 views
M
Replying to @barristersecret
True that the current story doesn't add up: imo something must have turned up which made Keir Starmer realise he hadn't been told the full story - that's the only reading of events that makes sense of him being OK with it at first + now not
48,950 views
J
Replying to @barristersecret
I'm conflicted by this story. On the one hand I agree with everything you say: the story doesn't hold. But I also wonder whether redemption is something we actually believe in. But if she is still spinning a line then perhaps she hasn't achieved it.
48,950 views
B
Replying to @barristersecret
The other thing is what could she possibly gain? It’s a work phone so belongs to her employer, unless she was putting it on eBay the best she could get is an upgrade.
48,950 views
S
Replying to @barristersecret
This is a useful and insightful explanation. Hope you've put it on Twitter too - it'll get the attention it needs there. 👍
48,950 views
A
Replying to @barristersecret
I am not at all surprised that the Police chased a woman for a potential case of a wrongfully claimed lost phone while the SA conviction rate is 1%
48,950 views
H
Replying to @barristersecret
Yes, definitely some oddity around it. Will be interested to see if more comes out.
48,950 views
R
Replying to @barristersecret
In the US there is something called an Alford plea where the accused can enter a plea of guilty without admitting guilt. The judge can grant or deny the plea.
48,950 views
G
Replying to @barristersecret
Why did someone press charges in the first place. I lost my phone tons of times and I certainly can't count the amount of times I lost my debit card canceled it but then found it 2/3days later.
48,950 views