Post

11 replies
D
in my understanding, you always want to see things sorted by oldest first, so you would select that and the setting would stay (and you can do that now too). what do you mean by bouncing between modes? i assume you’re not interested in other sorting modes?
10,240,330 views
6
G
Replying to @danabra
What would you call "always adding a reply worthwhile" other than "constant engagement"? IMO the value of a conversation is not always related with its freshness, so why bother adding that? Why force that down the throat of newcomers?
4,850 views
G
Replying to @geovanisouza92
If the conversation worth to me, I would be willing to "adding a reply" later, maybe restarting the conversation. So, I don't need an algorithm for that.
4,850 views
D
Replying to @geovanisouza92
if the post you’re replying to is even moderately popular, the vast majority of people will never see your reply — it’ll be too far down. even if you have something interesting to contribute. and any conversation you restart would be at a huge disadvantage compared to initial comments
4,850 views
Replies
D
Replying to @danabra
if we stay within the bounds of purely chronological settings, “newest first” solves this by giving every reply a fair chance of at least being seen. but it also completely buries interesting conversations that people have found valuable over time. hotness tries to balance those concerns.
4,850 views
M
Replying to @danabra
I think "hotness sort with decay" (which I assume this is anyways) is probably the fairest system overall. It has worked really well for reddit.
4,850 views
G
Replying to @danabra
Fair. To me, quite-replying seems more effective, because that amplifies the conversation to my network, not only with the original authors.
4,850 views