Post

37 replies
I
After being very much on the back foot, it feels like supporters of assisted dying have the momentum going into tomorrow's debate. Interventions in their favour from David Cameron and David Neuberger, sensible movement on an independent commission on palliative care & a letter from Esther Rantzen.
11,879,110 views
24
E
Replying to @iandunt
If I was famous I wouldn't want my legacy to be enabling suicide for the vulnerable. I'd fight for better palliative care, not leave desperately ill, vulnerable or disabled people with a final agonising choice, whether to end their lives by suicide. I know it's complex but a terrible legacy imv.
13,950 views
A
Replying to @eagleowlsheila
Palliative care should be improved obviously…. But it is not enough in some cases where assisted dying should be a right
13,950 views
E
Replying to @alec10k
People already have the right to end their lives; sadly I think this will inevitably mean some vulnerable people being led towards it. Also it will reduce what should be a clamour for better palliative care. I'd rather have enough pain meds even if I'm dead afterwards than have to choose suicide...
13,950 views
D
Replying to @eagleowlsheila
It's not reasonable to argue that people already have a right to end their lives, because they are denied safe means to do so. There is a high risk of failure with frequently catastrophic consequences. Not everyone feels as you do. I would rather choose an earlier death than palliative care.
13,950 views
E
Replying to @davidfutyan
I assume "it's not reasonable" means "I don't agree with you"? So on that basis you'd make it easier for suicidal people with mental health issues to "do it right"? As they are also seeking to end intolerable pain.
13,950 views
Replies
E
Replying to @eagleowlsheila
PS where did I say everyone feels the same as me?? Now that's what I call unreasonable:)
13,950 views
D
Replying to @eagleowlsheila
That's a straw man. It's not what the bill in question is about. What you wrote implied that if someone in situations addressed by the bill wishes to end their own life they are already able to do so, negating the need for the bill. That implication is what I argue is unreasonable.
13,950 views