Post

45 replies
R
In your "opinion", up against a lying state, that broke every promise it made, but fine you hold your grudge, good luck finding the millions of pounds needed to replace them, us SNP members will keep funding the indy movement, no one else is, they just attack us and do bugger all else but moan.
12,005,350 views
32
R
Replying to @roybennett
No party is automatically entitled to our votes. Pro independence progressives may feel it's wrong to vote for a party that has a DFM who holds views that belong in the dark ages or a party that supports freeports that will undermine the argument for independence. It's the SNP that's changed.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
Fine. I look forward to them replicating the hundreds of millions of pounds the SNP invested, the entire lives of those who laid the groundwork, etc, etc which we both know isn`t going to happen, just looking at the utter inability of non SNP voters to even raise .10p a week for indy shows you that.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
Not all pro independence voters vote SNP, and there are other parties that support independence. I'll never vote for a unionist party, but that doesn't mean I'll vote for a party that doesn't reflect my views. They changed and lost our support, and that's not our fault.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
Other parties ? name one that has managed to fund itself, is credible and got elected, they don`t exist.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
There are other pro indy parties that will be on the ballot in 2026. That's all most folk care about. The majority aren't loyal to one party. One thing is for sure, though, blaming potentially sympathetic voters for not supporting a party that doesn't represent their views won't get you their vote.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
Name them, they`re not electable and have little to no funding or govt experience. "Most folk" wheres your real data to support that claim I`m not "blaming" you, pointing out the consequences of the choices being made isn`t "blame" its called placing responsibility and accountability where it lays
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
If I don't vote SNP and believe me talking to you, it is making that much more likely, I'll vote Green. Others might vote for Alba. If the SNP doesn't reflect the priorities of voters, then voters don't owe them anything, and your sense of angry entitlement to their vote will alienate even more.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
Greens actively undermine the SNP reducing thier support, Alba can`t get elected and face a much bigger climb now the Salmond has tragically passed on, who will fund them now is anybody`s guess. I`m not even sure they will be able to finance themselves any further, voters don`t fund Scottish parties
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
You still don't get it. Why would anyone vote for a party that doesn't reflect their views and has senior members with bigoted views?It's the SNP that's changed,not the former members and voters you're angry at. I might still vote SNP,but the Greens now reflect my views more accurately than the SNP.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
Don`t vote for them then, just don`t complain when the only parties you can choose from are the big 3 that the wealthy own. Why should I pay for you to have a choice ? Pay for your own choice, but you don`t want to do that do you ? You are happy others are paying so you can have a "free" choice.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
Away and chase yersel. Until the SNP changes, it's not going to win the people it's lost back, and God knows it needs them. Maybe you're right, and it's had its day, but we'll find out one way or the other. Life goes on.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
Do you financially support any of the political parties you vote for ? or do you expect all the work that goes in to give you a choice to be done for nothing ? genuinely asking, if not, how do you expect them to exist ? I`m genuinely asking.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
I used to give to the SNP until last year. My membership money and donations at elections, etc. Since I left the party, I haven't given to any party as I don't feel that committed and essentially I'm a floating indy voter. I do give to some money to the likes of Yes Scotland but not much.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
Its the dropping membership numbers that are fueling the rise of Swinney/Forbes, and no I don`t like them, but as the income falls the business sector gains ground as the only backer left, and we all know where that ends, hence my cynicism toward many voters, they are often thier own worst enemy.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
Might have to go through a period of readjustment after Swinney/Forbes are gone. There's plenty of gifted young SNP folk just waiting. More modern thinking and crucially more appealing to their own generation. We can worry and argue, but it's the turn of the young and all power to them.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
If they go, once the wealthy get control, they will anoint Forbes in his place, that campaign started a decade ago, unlike voters the wealthy are patient and think in decades not election cycles, the young talent that doesn`t comply will be driven out and yet another party will be controlled.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
That's bleak. Hope it doesn't go that way, but it could. We live in a time when everything is controlled by the elite, and we live in a very managed 'democracy'. Nobody knows for sure how things will develop in Scotland and worldwide, but there is resistance, and I still have hope.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @rantinscot
That's reality, plenty of us keep telling other voters, but as my union secretary dad used to tell me beer, football and instant gratification is why workers stay workers and the wealthy stay in control, one thinks in decades/lifetimes, the other weeks, months, rarely more than a year ahead.
16,750 views
R
Replying to @roybennett
Your dad is right. It's gone from bread and circuses in Roman times to Netflix, Love Island, and the Premier league today. There's only ever progress when there's a good dose of working class consciousness, and there's little sign of that today. I don't have decades left, but I'll do what I can.
16,750 views
Replies
R
Replying to @rantinscot
Me too we can agree to disagree and I share your frustration, ironically its that frustration the wealthy seek to take advantage of though, so we do what we can and try not to be put off, although at times I find myself wanting to punch something, the miners union taught me the value of patience
16,750 views