J
Alas, discovered what the memes about Musk and D&D are about. Apparently somebody said middle-aged conservative white guy Gary Gygax was a middle-aged conservative white guy. Seems this was slanderous and disrespectful. Musk didn't respond with that, somebody else did; Musk outsources his opinions.
12,769,420 views
J
Replying to
@jonathanlhoward
But Musk was there in a flash, calling Gygax a genius and anybody who disagrees is a monster. Hello. Monster here. Gygax was not a genius. He was a middling game designer who was first to market with an idea that was popping up all over the wargaming world. This is very well documented.
5,900 views
J
Replying to
@jonathanlhoward
I bought Gygax's ROLE-PLAYING MASTERY in '87. It bothered me. Some passages were very "My way or the highway," very dismissive of other approaches. Also, extraordinarily gate-keepy. Also, organisationally a mess. No coherence in his arguments. It did not strike me as the work of a genius.
5,900 views
J
Replying to
@jonathanlhoward
in '92, I bought DANGEROUS JOURNEYS: MYTHUS. Gorgeously produced for the time, excellent work by GDW. Unhappily, they were polishing a turd. Obsessively rules heavy, very much a 1st gen design when we were already well into more coherent rulesets. It was a mess.
5,900 views
J
Replying to
@jonathanlhoward
In '96 I picked up CYBORG COMMANDO in a sale. I'm so relieved that I paid almost nothing for it. Rather than try to sum it up here, I will direct you to the infamous (and very funny) RPG net review. Trust me, it's worth reading. Spoiler: Not a work of genius. www.rpg.net/reviews/arch...
5,900 views
J
Replying to
@jonathanlhoward
Am I dissing Gygax? To a degree. He was certainly very keen to be seen as "The Genius Who Created Roleplaying In General And D&D in Particular." He marginalised Dave Arneson. He dropped the ball badly with TSR. But, seen in context, he's not so bad, and was apparently quite an affable guy.
5,900 views
J
Replying to
@jonathanlhoward
But was he the genius that Musk, a man strangely wedded to "Great Man" narratives for some reason, says he was? No. He was a middle-aged conservative white guy of middling ability who happened to be in the right place at the right time. Oh. Maybe I can see why Musk is so invested in this after all.
5,900 views
Replies
M