A
I can totally believe a monarch who acted like Miriel would get overthrown, but I wanted her to be smarter. Regarding Elendil, I have no idea why he didn't blockade Armenelos until Pharazon backed down. He controlled the whole ass navy.
21,769,360 views
S
Replying to
@arobertswrites
i think this is related to one of my gripes with the show that society seems flat? like their isn’t a navy as much as theres a guy who’s in charge of a navy if that makes sense.
5,200 views
A
Replying to
@starshine
Yeah, although tbh that's how I feel about the LotR films too, although the books help make up some of the difference.
5,200 views
S
Replying to
@arobertswrites
def but i that had a tighter narrative cuz it’s largely just following the fellowship so it wasn’t as important compared to the type of story(ies) they want to tell
5,200 views
A
Replying to
@starshine
Yeah I think the biggest structural issue with ROP (which is the source of a bunch of other issues) is that it tries to be about everything and everyone even when that doesn't make sense.
5,200 views
A
Replying to
@arobertswrites
I actually like the Harfoot narrative because I'm trash for goofy 80s fantasy but what's it doing in the same show as the fall of Numenor
5,200 views
Replies
S
Replying to
@arobertswrites
yeah it’s going to be hard to tie that narrative together, i’m guessing her and gandalf start a rhunish insurrection and get the ent wives to go to war over the next two season
5,200 views