Post

30 replies
M
The dingy wall vs clean wall Notre Dame discussion makes me think of how “silent film” filters always have scratches and other damage. We have a hard time processing old things in a fresh state.
22,237,900 views
10
M
Replying to @moviessilently
Print quality was very important to theater management in the silent era. Trade publications are full of complaints for battered prints and praise for clean ones. Producers would announce new methods to prevent “rainstorms” (scratched up prints)
11,500 views
M
Replying to @moviessilently
Restoration and the response to it is such a fascinating topic and I imagine there will be a lot of it as this is probably the most famous repair job in the world, well, this week anyway
11,500 views
M
Replying to @moviessilently
There’s an argument to be made that the soot is as much part of history as the architecture but then again, I am not sure how it could be restored without building several huge coal factories in the immediate vicinity.
11,500 views
P
Replying to @moviessilently
I don't think it's a particularly good argument, it just comes from a place of familiarity, like saying paintings shouldn't be cleaned because you're used to the dark moody look of yellowed varnish
11,500 views
B
Replying to @pseudandry
That argument was used during the restoration of the Sistine Chapel. I can see both sides of the argument to be honest, but I come down on the cleaning.
11,500 views
M
Replying to @brentmichaud
I do as well but I would hate to see the Vasa painted
11,500 views
B
Replying to @moviessilently
Do they actually have surviving pigment for that? Would be interesting to see a computer model if so.
11,500 views
M
Replying to @brentmichaud
They compromised by displaying the pigments and painted replicas of the figures alongside the blackened wreck, which I think was the correct decision
11,500 views
Replies
B
Replying to @moviessilently
Cool. I'll have to check that out.
11,500 views