C
You cannot dissipate the charge in the atmosphere with an array of poles or other “lightning prevention” devices. The charge imbalance is too high. See: journals.ametsoc.org/view/journal... Some ordinance and space facilities use tall towers and catenary to redirect charge away. ⚡️🧪🧵 (1/11)
21,652,420 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
A paper presented at the International Conference on #Lightning Protection in 2022 shows that "Lightning Prevention" devices DO NOT work, agreeing with previous studies. It’s a wonder so many MLB ballparks, cities, and others. use these devices? #LightningSafety (2/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
Two truths about lightning: 1. You cannot predict when or where it will strike 2. You cannot prevent it from happening (3/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
The math is against any one location being struck by #lightning. Lightning prevention/suppression appears to “work” because it’s not very likely that whatever you’re trying to protect is going to be struck in the first place. (4/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
Lightning channel is 1-2" in diameter. Assume: 1.5" average, or 3.81e-5 km diameter. Area = π*r*r = π*1.9e-5*1.9e-5 = 5.98e-5 square kilometers/stroke. A tiny area of the planet as big around as a ping pong ball is hit every time lightning strikes. (5/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
Assume that the peak lightning CG stroke density in the U.S. is 32 strokes/km AND each stroke hits a different point on Earth: 32*5.98e-5 = 1.9e-3 square kilometers total area struck by lightning in the peak region for lightning in the U.S. (6/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
1 square kilometer is the same as ~187 football fields. Place 187 football fields side by side, and randomly place 32 ping pong balls on them. THAT is how much lightning hits the ground in the peak lightning areas in the U.S. in a given year. (7/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
Think of it this way. 0.000003648% of the most lightning prone area of the U.S. gets struck by lightning in a given year. [(1.767 square inches * 32)/1.55e9 square inches]*100 (8/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
So if that is all the area that is getting struck by lightning, the probability of any area being struck by lightning is very low. Lightning prevention counts on this fact! (9/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
Great American Ballpark had "Lightning Suppression" devices installed in May 2019. Lightning Suppression devices do not prevent #lightning. Between June 2019 and April 2022, 255 lightning events occurred within 1 km of GABP, including at the stadium itself. (10/11)
5,900 views
C
Replying to
@coweatherman
The best way to stay safe from lightning is to avoid it. Delay games when lightning is in the area. You cannot predict when and where lightning will strike, and you cannot prevent it. (11/11)
5,900 views
Replies
No replies yet.