Post

34 replies
N
So if the Theia hypothesis is correct, the solar system used to have 10 planets , yes?
18,728,020 views
19
Replies
N
Replying to @nameshiv
Yes Pluto is a planet, nobody cares what the nerds think about clearing debris in the area go clean your room area
12,900 views
D
Replying to @nameshiv
If Pluto is a planet, you'll be lobbying for Houmea, Eris and others to be recognized as planets, yes?
12,900 views
F
Replying to @nameshiv
That, or somebody lost a moon. Plenty of Jupiter and Saturn's are planet sized
12,900 views
B
Replying to @nameshiv
Theia (like Earth at the time) was a protoplanet, there was likely many bodies we could have called planets at that point in the solar system that were eventually thrown out due to gravitational interactions or were involved in a collision at some point (early solar system was chaotic as hell)
12,900 views
I
Replying to @nameshiv
theia hit the earth back during the time when there were hundreds (maybe even thousands) of planetesimals around slamming into each other. the plantestimals were formed after the sun ignited from huge accretion discs. it's a whole thing with the early solar system lol
12,900 views
M
Replying to @nameshiv
Add a zero.
12,900 views
J
Replying to @nameshiv
It definitely had lots more, and the Theia impact was just one of many in the consolidation process.
12,900 views
C
Replying to @nameshiv
I thnk if we count Theia as a planet, we should also count some proto planets in the asteroid belt and some Trans-Neptunian objects as well.
12,900 views
D
Replying to @nameshiv
Hi, I did a PhD in planetary sciences. The early solar system was filled with 100s of protoplanets and planetesimals. These either collided with one another or were ejected from the solar system. The Theia hypothesis refers to the specific collision that would have formed the Earth-moon system.
12,900 views
C
Replying to @nameshiv
At the time the solar system would have been filled with rocky bodies of various sizes called "planetesimals"
12,900 views
S
Replying to @nameshiv
Theia must have been so annoyed. There it was, just floating around the Solar System as a full planet but one collision with the Earth later, and not only does it get destroyed but it gets demoted to a mere 'protoplanet'! 😉
12,900 views
R
Replying to @nameshiv
Not science but Theia finding a place in popular culture: “So, perhaps our Theia’s collision Was not just a cosmic death But also a means of fusion And the day we took our first breath” #Theia #KingGizzard #TheSilverCord #ProgRock #lizard #wizard youtu.be/3jnsD-fEHdY?...
12,900 views
M
Replying to @nameshiv
If Theia existed it did so at a time when none of the current planets would meet the definition of a planet, so the historic number of planets is moot. It is possible that traces of Theia can still be detected in planet Earth. youtu.be/bDQ4aLsbsk0
12,900 views
B
Replying to @nameshiv
Tricky... because of the "clearing the orbit" thingy that disqualified Pluto, the presence of Theia would mean that the proto-Earth was not a planet. But then all our current co-orbitals also prove that case. #PlutoIsAPlanet boy did we have fun with that one!
12,900 views
H
Replying to @nameshiv
Guess we had a cosmic eviction...
12,900 views
K
Replying to @nameshiv
Planet 9 (the ice giant, not me) is a bit of an urban legend around these parts. Legend has it, planetoids that migrate too far out get caught and imprisoned in wildly eccentric and long orbits, driven mad with isolation. buut that's just a legend, obviously none of us are gonna test that theory.
12,900 views