C
Hi #booksky admin here! 📝📚💙 I've been getting requests to filter out the #bookchallenge posts from BookSky because they are repetitive and annoying. Personally, I love this plan but I want to take a poll. Repost if you would like me to remove them. Heart this post if they should stay.
21,989,770 views
Replies
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
Please note, only the posts correctly tagged #bookchallenge will be removed. I am not a wizard and cannot remove posts in which people misspell or omit hashtags. 💔
56,650 views
S
Replying to
@clarabelle
It would be much more interesting if people shared why they love the book, what it has meant to them, etc.
56,650 views
D
Replying to
@clarabelle
I was about to stop posting book challenge days for the same reason. While I’ve added quite a few that I’ve seen to my wish list… all the meaningful book posts get lost.
56,650 views
J
Replying to
@clarabelle
Those posts are the main reason I check this feed. It's an easy way to find other users with similar taste in books.
56,650 views
D
Replying to
@clarabelle
I like #EarthShakerReads. The books that shook your foundation, and in what ways it changed you.
56,650 views
D
Replying to
@clarabelle
I enjoy scrolling through them but I get the annoying part, too
56,650 views
N
M
E
Replying to
@clarabelle
I mean i see tons of books i've never heard of (and many books I've read) and yes you're going to get duplicates but there's just so much variety - i think tomorrow i'm going to hit a book many haven't read (might not know of it) but it's pretty important to a certain topic people LOVE to talk about
56,650 views
B
Replying to
@clarabelle
I enjoy seeing them. Of course they are repetitive. Many of the books are great reads. If you are part of the challenge, you are invested in the results.
56,650 views
H
Replying to
@clarabelle
I personally just find it easier to mute the hashtag, so others can enjoy what they like. 🤷🏻
56,650 views
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
I definitely find that they drown out the other posts, but I just muted some of the key words, and that way I can see the rest. I think if most people enjoy them, I don’t want to take that away from them. I just wish there was actual commentary, not just images. Would be way more interesting.
56,650 views
P
Replying to
@clarabelle
I actually muted the words "20 book" for this very reason. I forgot those posts existed. Yeah they feel a bit repetitive and take up too much of the thread.
56,650 views
R
Replying to
@clarabelle
I WILL stop "spamming" if you UNcensor me. Ironically, you "judged by the cover" if it was due to my username... but given history's religious tyranny. (To present day!) At least do me the courtesy of skimming it and then judge? It’s public domain, so it's easy to do. archive.org/details/conq...
56,650 views
M
M
R
Replying to
@clarabelle
I have found the book challenge very interesting. Usually people just post what they are reading, but this is books they may not have read for years. I even like the repetitive aspect, of seeing different people being moved by the same books.
56,650 views
D
Replying to
@clarabelle
How sad. I, personally love seeing them, have my want to list and I love chatting with folk who read the same books
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
💙 I’m enjoying the book challenge. For those of us new to BlueSky, it’s acted as a kind of “get acquainted” tool. BookSky was easy to find as it came up when I looked at topics. 🤷🏼♀️ What is the discussion focus of BookSky?
56,650 views
S
Replying to
@clarabelle
I've noticed some annoying repetition with some 20 books challenge. I think there should be a limit on how many times they can repost the same thing.
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
You must read A Game of Thrones!!! None of this TV show HOGWASH!!! blog-on-books.blogspot.com/2024/09/why-...
56,650 views
D
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
I’m really enjoying it, lots of books I’ve never heard of…and isn’t it what booksky should be used for?
56,650 views
N
Replying to
@clarabelle
Well boooo to this idea. I’ve found new-to-me books with this challenge and a nice reminder to re-read a few. My vote is it stays 🤞🏾
56,650 views
B
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love seeing these posts. They help me find like-minded people to follow on this app. I look forward every day to discover new books 📚 on these post also.
56,650 views
E
Replying to
@clarabelle
If people are annoyed with them they should just filter them themselves. A lot of people seem to be enjoying them and I've had a few spark discussions about authors. I'd hate to see this feed start forcing filters on others for hashtags that are driving engagement for #Booksky.
56,650 views
J
Replying to
@clarabelle
I muted them because I want people to have fun but also I am not having fun.
56,650 views
D
Replying to
@clarabelle
I think challenges like this drum up further discussion; I know I've already had a few great talks with people about certain books, and have added bunches to my to-read on Storygraph. It's amazing to see how we all came to love the same hobby through different paths
56,650 views
K
Replying to
@clarabelle
Personally I wish this challenge had its own separate feed, but that’s just my opinion. I’ve muted most of the tags/keywords, but people don’t use the same ones consistently, so I still get them spamming my feed sometimes, which is annoying. 😕
56,650 views
C
O
Replying to
@clarabelle
Oh no! Ive been using both hashtags in my challenge posts... Should I only be using the book challenge hashtag to make them easier to filter off for uninterested users?
56,650 views
F
Replying to
@clarabelle
I like the #bookchallenge posts. I'm finding people, who from their profile, seem totally different from me but like the same book
56,650 views
R
Replying to
@clarabelle
I’m with those who think we can mute them ourselves. They do get repetitive. I imagine they’ll end after a while but 20 days is a lot
56,650 views
B
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
I like it. Gives me ideas for books to read. Maybe create a BookSky genre only for book challenges?
56,650 views
E
Replying to
@clarabelle
I don't mind them. They've helped me add books to my list when modern books are added. It's just that there's a lot of them with a lot of the same few classic books, is all.
56,650 views
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
...what's the point of doing the challenge if the hashtag is buried? There's no way users have read every single book shared through the challenge.
56,650 views
L
R
Replying to
@clarabelle
I don't mind them existing and it's nice to see them occasionally, but they're so frequent they clog up the feeds. I wish I could just see like, a random 10% of them. I occasionally mute them.
56,650 views
L
Replying to
@clarabelle
I propose you do this poll in another way and not through reposting
56,650 views
J
Replying to
@clarabelle
This is the main reason I’ve been visiting Booksky. I like to see what books have influenced others and what I might like to add to my “to read” list
56,650 views
K
Replying to
@clarabelle
Perhaps encourage users who don't want to see the #BookChallenge posts to use the mute words function...? 🙂
56,650 views
2
Replying to
@clarabelle
One of the main reasons i check. Feels a bit totalitarian to remove it when people can filter it themselves
56,650 views
J
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love the challenge as is. Fascinating to discover new reads, and a welckmed icebreaker to get started on bluesky.
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
I lost interest after #5 or 6, so I don’t mind. But I don’t believe anyone who’s says they’ve finished Infinite Jest, so do with that what you will.
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
I’m not sure what the problem is about removing them. People can always search that # if they want to find book recommendations.
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
I have to confess that I am debating whether to stop following #BookSky because I would rather not have to scroll through endless book covers.
56,650 views
D
D
Replying to
@clarabelle
Yes, remove. Its like a chain letter. If people want to recommend a book, by all means, post about it. I want to hear WHY the book was so important to them.
56,650 views
G
Replying to
@clarabelle
Call me a curmudgeon if you must, but without the hashtag many people will be struggling to find new books recommended to them by Booksky members and thus will be missing out on the chance to expand their literary horizon. I say let the trend stay.
56,650 views
B
Replying to
@clarabelle
Yes, please! Booksky is full of them and it makes scrolling through to find genuinely interesting posts a bit of a drag. Random book cover pics don't elicit conversation about the books.
56,650 views
G
Replying to
@clarabelle
I'm not usually one to partake but have on this becsuse I love books and as others have said its a good chance to connect with people I might not otherwise. That said I could do without the preamble
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love the challenge. It's a great way of finding new books. And I also like to know why people liked that book so...I ask them. For me it creates conversation anyway.
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
Maybe you can make that a separate Book sky thread so that the people who do enjoy them can keep enjoying them and those who don't then don't have to see them?
56,650 views
L
Replying to
@clarabelle
I’ve enjoyed participating and also seeing others posts. They have given me some ideas (and new book purchases!) too
56,650 views
L
Replying to
@clarabelle
Just ignore them. I agree with others who've said they'd like to now why people liked them and I did a short thread like that of five or so. SUrely the mute function could already be used if people want to not see them in the first place.
56,650 views
P
Replying to
@clarabelle
What impresses me most about this post and its many responses are the number of people who've participated openly without regard to the nature of the poster's profile. If this isn't nerd heaven, I don't know what else is.
56,650 views
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
I like the challenge posts. It's helped me to find people to follow.
56,650 views
P
Replying to
@clarabelle
Keep them. You can always mute if they are not to your taste. I find the 'lack' of explanation is the interesting part because it makes me actively ask myself the question 'why would someone really care about that book'?
56,650 views
B
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love it & the lack of text is a great way for shy posters & neurodivergent folk to engage on here & find their feet #booksky #actuallyautistic
56,650 views
G
Replying to
@clarabelle
#bookchallenge is my absolute most favourite thing ever on social media 📚💙
56,650 views
E
Replying to
@clarabelle
I think it is the twenty DAY part. I’ve got quite a bit of enjoyment and interaction from this, but will speed through my remaining DAYs this weekend.
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
Well, personally, I like it, although I tend to post books which are written in my language or translate to it. Mostly because I'm not sure how many of my followers read on English and I don't want to look like I'm show off.
56,650 views
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
Can we just drown it in something more meaningful? 7 books that have stayed with you or influenced you, each with one sentence about why?
56,650 views
D
Replying to
@clarabelle
I’m enjoying reflecting on what I’ve read and have added a few books to my “to read” list thanks to other reader’s posts. That being said, if they’re suffocating constructive discussions, then I’m fine just using the hashtag when I want to see the lists.
56,650 views
R
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love seeing what others read! It helps me find like-minded souls and gives me ideas of what new books to explore.
56,650 views
J
Replying to
@clarabelle
It's community building. The danger is this site ends up like Threads did and dies a slow death. Maybe set an end date of Christmas but run it for one month a year for new people. #bookchallenge #booksky
56,650 views
L
Replying to
@clarabelle
I vote for leaving it in. I've gotten conversation, found some new books, and found some followers/people to follow. Why filter posts of books that people find impactful? Not every post is for every person. That's why we can control our own feeds. But, #booksky should be, well, books.
56,650 views
S
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love the book challenge! The only thing I’ve found annoying about this thread is the pinned posts 😅😅 Not the actual posts but the fact that I have to scroll so far to get to the thread lol If there’s a way to maybe just have a link to the instructions pinned at the top? 🖤
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
They are the only posts I see, so it kinda turned me off to BookSky. I don’t check the feed as often. I was excited to find the feed, and now it’s just meh….
56,650 views
F
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
Honestly think without the book challenge the booksky tag would be super quiet. People getting annoyed should just mute it.
56,650 views
O
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love the book challenge posts, too. I see books I know nothing about. Please keep them.
56,650 views
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
💙 the book challenge has presented me with books I've not thought of for awhile and some that are now on my to-read list. Keep them coming is my thought.
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
On Android, press and hold a hashtag to bring up an option to follow or MUTE a given hashtag
56,650 views
N
Replying to
@clarabelle
Keep the #bookchallenge. People not interested can mute. For people that love books and love to read these challenges are a great way to discover new books or be reminded to read the ones you own, but have not yet read.
56,650 views
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
The more people choose the same book just shows how influential that book is.
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
I want them to stay. I think the point of BookSky should be to talk about and recommend books. The book challenges have introduced and reminded me of so many books I have/want to enjoy. Plus they are one of the most fun things I have found on BS that combines community and books.
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
I see many are saying they would be more interesting if we knew why they were significant. This is where it would be beneficial to ask the person who posted the book. I like that they don’t have to provide one for every book, but can answer specific questions about specific books.
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
The terms of the poll ("like" to stay, "repost" to remove) incentivize the response that you yourself want. In other words, I find those posts repetitive and annoying and don't want them; but neither do I want to repost this...
56,650 views
E
Replying to
@clarabelle
I like finding titles I have skipped. I think the "no commentary" comment is counterproductive. Of course we want to know what makes a book special!! #BookSky
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
❤️. They may be repetitive, but everyone should be able to post their books and have it filtered out because someone else read it
56,650 views
K
Replying to
@clarabelle
The book challenge posts are the only thing that keeps me coming back to Bluesky. Keep them please.
56,650 views
M
Replying to
@clarabelle
Yes plz remove-we could still find them through the hashtag right?
56,650 views
N
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love the book challenge posts, but for those who dislike them it’s really not that difficult to mute a hashtag. Part of what I like about BlueSky is it encourages people to take control of their feeds
56,650 views
B
Replying to
@clarabelle
I like the book challenge. I learn about people and books. It's deeply personal. Why else do we read?
56,650 views
B
Replying to
@clarabelle
Imo if you take away book challenge you will just have promotional feeds left.
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
Did these posts put me off scrolling booksky because they were all I was seeing? Yes. Did I figure out how to mute them? Also yes. So now I get to see the feed I like and so does everyone else.
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
I’m actually really sad to learn that people find the book challenge posts annoying. I was loving making my choices and engaging with people about our favorites. This has kind of killed it for me.
56,650 views
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
I am participating in the strictly book covers challenge. It's my way back to a place like this & people can guess or remember the impact of a book. I will come back to fill in the whys after it's done. Is it the content getting repeated or something else?
56,650 views
S
Replying to
@clarabelle
I love them, but they have taken over the feed. I'd like both, in two feeds.
56,650 views
K
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
Please do not. For 3 reasons. It makes me rediscover books I read when I was younger. Also, I have now pictures of about 50 book covers of books I would like to read. It gives a quick glimpse into the interests of the person who is posting, which is great when you are looking to follow more people.
56,650 views
I
Replying to
@clarabelle
I like the book challenge. It's a good way to get some recommendation or reminders of those we've forgotten. It's already impacted my hold lists with my library.
56,650 views
C
Replying to
@clarabelle
Isn’t the point of it that it starts conversations and find like-minded/interesting people, though? It seems counter-productive to filter them out. People can just… scroll.
56,650 views
N
Replying to
@clarabelle
I agree, it's an interesting challenge but there are too many posts.
56,650 views
A
Replying to
@clarabelle
I find it sad that some people would rather complain to admin & impose their will on others when they could simply use the mute function. It’s also sad that something that seemed like a fun icebreaker now feels unwelcome. I hope that other people will continue with the challenge, but I’m done.
56,650 views
K
Replying to
@clarabelle
I think people who don’t want to see them should mute the hashtag on their own accounts. 🤷♀️
56,650 views
N
Replying to
@clarabelle
I think it sets a very dangerous precedent to “filter out” something as harmless (and fun for a lot of people!) as the #bookchallenge when people can easily mute the hashtag. Personally, it was what drew me to this platform in the first place and the reason I keep coming back.
56,650 views
B