L
Kim Leadbeater making extremely powerful speech opening the Assisted Dying debate. Perhaps consciously echoes language around abortion rights. Closes by saying: "The right to choose does not take away the right not to choose."
23,813,500 views
E
Replying to
@lewisgoodall
It's a nice soundbite, but the "right not to choose" will not always be respected. Some people will be suggestible, vulnerable, in pain when they shouldn't be, and/or regarded by others as having a life not worth living. I don't think any safeguards can protect the most vulnerable from pressure.
18,500 views
J
Replying to
@eagleowlsheila
So you think it is better for not choosing to be imposed? It isn't more ethical to force one group of people to suffer unnecessarily than it is to provide choice with appropriate safeguards.
18,500 views
E
Replying to
@johnsays
An interesting and inappropriate way of framing it... Anyway well done for being on the winning side.
18,500 views
J
Replying to
@eagleowlsheila
I don't see what's inappropriate about it. The status quo is objectively abusive to terminally ill people. We have to face up to the fact that there is a balance of harms here and that accepting the status quo does not mean there is no harm.
18,500 views
J
Replying to
@johnsays
Many people seem to think that a society must never be trusted to come up with checks and balances, even if that means condemning some people to a prolonged and agonising end. I think we can embrace the complexity and seek to genuinely mitigate the harm on both sides of this.
18,500 views
E
Replying to
@johnsays
Good palliative care should never mean condemning ppl to that kind of death. Now we'll lose the imperative to fix it plus vulnerable ppl will have to make this agonising choice, sometimes under coercion to end their own lives. I really don't see how suicide is any kind of societal progress...
18,500 views
J
Replying to
@eagleowlsheila
The problem is that some terminal illnesses are so painful and debilitating that all the palliative care in the world doesn't help. Consider people with diseases like MND who cannot escape the complete loss of bodily function and the indignity that comes with that. Now you might argue that they
18,500 views
J
Replying to
@johnsays
shouldn't feel that way, but they do and it is entirely reasonable that they do. When the end us inevitable anyway, we don't have to force people to endure that absolute worst.
18,500 views
E
Replying to
@johnsays
Indeed and that's exactly what I'm saying :/ Suicide is not a good solution to nasty diseases.
18,500 views
E
Replying to
@eagleowlsheila
Anyway I'm assuming your family has no history of disabled ppl being treated like they're dying just because their legs don't work! We can agree to disagree but suicide is never an answer to anything imv.
18,500 views
J
Replying to
@eagleowlsheila
On what possible level do you think I am advocating for people to undergo assisted dying because they need a wheelchair? Please don't mirepresent me.
18,500 views
E
Replying to
@johnsays
I'm not. I!m suggesting that no one could understand how disabled ppl and the very elderly are treated unless they've seen it first hand. Anyway signing off as I need to care for a disabled person who the NHS is keen to give up on as her knees don't work :/
18,500 views
Replies
No replies yet.