Post

15 replies
A
Maybe legacy policy from Biden? He wants to place the blame on Ukraine for his own crappy performance. "Look, we gave them all the weapons they needed but they refused to mobilize enough men to handle them". BS. Ukraine mobilized more than a million men at the end of Feb 2022.
18,133,450 views
12
J
Replying to @andersostlund
This is not hypocritical. The US draft always targeted men starting at 18. I was called down for the draft during the Vietnam war. Everyone in line was 18.
6,250 views
C
Replying to @johnmullin74
There is absolutely no reason why Ukraine should follow exactly the same model for conscription as USA. There is however strong reason why it should not, and it's called "age pyramid". Dip from age 15 to 25 because Ukraine was invaded in 2014 www.populationpyramid.net/ukraine/2023/
6,250 views
J
Replying to @codepocalypse
That's good argument. But another angle is the human capital argument. Unless this war is going to last 10 years, you want to keep older people working in the economy rather than on the front lines.
6,250 views
C
Replying to @johnmullin74
For Ukraine it is more important that the younger people make families first. Once you have a child or two, even if you die, the demography will not suffer so much. If, on the other hand you die young, the next generation will be even smaller. Demography is (probably) more important than economy.
6,250 views
C
Replying to @codepocalypse
"If Ukraine conscripts older men, it risks creating more widows and orphans who will likely depend on the state for survival. If it conscripts younger men, it risks further damaging the fertility rate and preventing more Ukrainians from being born at all." responsiblestatecraft.org/ukraine-2669...
6,250 views
C
Replying to @codepocalypse
"Ukraine was already facing a demographic crisis before the war began, and remains desperate to shield its younger adults. ... The result is a war increasingly fought by older men, supplemented by handfuls of young male and female volunteers." www.reuters.com/world/europe...
6,250 views
C
Replying to @codepocalypse
"Wars are generally bad for demographics. People in all age groups are being killed. In 2001, we had the lowest birth rate in the history of Ukraine. [...] This age group will shrink even further when exposed to increased mortality rates [associated with the war]." www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/202...
6,250 views
Replies
C
Replying to @codepocalypse
It was wrong of me to attribute this fall in population to the 2014 invasion of Crimea: "Dip from age 15 to 25 because Ukraine was invaded in 2014" but the fact remains that Ukraine is really in existential crisis, and sending young people to front will make it even worse.
6,250 views