D
Capitalism and Democracy: The Market is Far More Flexible than Christopher Caldwell Imagines (thread)
16,469,140 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
NYT columnist Christopher Caldwell devoted his Thanksgiving piece to describing the German sociologist Wolfgang Streeck’s views on capitalism and democracy. I have not read much of Streeck’s work, but as recounted by Caldwell, he gets many of the basic facts about the U.S. economy badly wrong.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
According to Caldwell’s account, capitalists were willing to sacrifice profits in the decades after World War II for stability. This meant less dynamism but allowed for broadly shared prosperity and thriving democratic institutions.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
“Between the end of World War II and the 1970s, he reminds us, working classes in Western countries won robust incomes and extensive protections. Profit margins suffered, of course, but that was in the nature of what Mr. Streeck calls the ‘postwar settlement.’ ....
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
What economies lost in dynamism, they gained in social stability.”
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
The problem with this account is that, at least in the United States there is no evidence that capitalists were sacrificing profit. Here’s after-tax corporate profits as a share of GDP since World War II. fred.stlouisfed.org/series/W273R...
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
As can be seen, it has only been in the years since the collapse of the housing bubble (the financial crisis) that profit shares consistently exceeded their average in the quarter century following World War II.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
(The rise in profit shares in the bubble years was largely illusory, as banks booked large profits on loans that subsequently went bad.)
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
There was also no lack of dynamism in this period when capital was supposedly sacrificing profit. The quarter century from 1947 to 1973 was by far the most rapid period of productivity growth the U.S. has seen. fred.stlouisfed.org/series/PRS85...
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
In Caldwell’s telling, the world economy was shaken by the oil price hikes in the 1980s and capital’s response was to change the rules to increase its take.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
The upward redistribution of income since 1980 has been widely documented, with the wages of ordinary workers no longer keeping pace with productivity growth. However, the gains were not going to corporate profits, or at least not until the years following the Great Recession.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
The redistribution was going from ordinary workers, like factory workers, construction workers, and retail clerks, to higher end workers like doctors, lawyers, engineers, as well as Wall Street types and top-level executives. This matters both from a political and economic standpoint.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
From a political standpoint, it is entirely reasonable that the ordinary workers who are losers in this story would resent the more highly educated workers who are the beneficiaries.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
There is even more reason for this resentment when we consider that the upward redistribution was done by deliberate policy, not just the natural working of the market.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
The most visible engineering was with trade policy. Our trade deals were crafted to put downward pressure on the pay of manufacturing workers by putting U.S. manufacturing workers in direct competition with low-paid workers in the developing world.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
The predicted and actual result of this policy was the loss of millions of manufacturing jobs and downward pressure on the wages of the remaining jobs.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
This policy was not “free trade.” There was no comparable effort to expose doctors and other highly paid professionals to the same sort of competition. It was a policy of selective protectionism.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
We also made patent and copyright protection longer and stronger, shifting more than $1 trillion annually from the rest of society to those in a position to benefit from these government-granted monopolies. www.cepr.net/report/profe...
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
These monopolies are a huge factor in the upward redistribution of income in the last half century. Bill Gates would still be working for a living if the government didn’t threaten to arrest anyone who copied Microsoft’s software without his permission.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
The government also chose to foster a bloated financial sector, which is another source of great fortunes in this period.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
Government support has taken a variety of forms, most visibly deposit insurance & bailouts in situations where the free market would put major financial firms out of business, but there are many other ways in which policy has encouraged the growth of the sector at the expense of economic efficiency.
14,300 views
J
Replying to
@deanbaker13
Love this, one question I have that. My understanding that some of the changes and impetus behind neoliberalism’s adoption were a response to stagflation. I often read that as a significant event and feel like I don’t have a great understanding of its origin in prior policies
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@jesseraccio
the seventies (actually 73-80) were a very bad decade. Economists still debate the cause. To my view, the main story was two huge hikes in oil prices (73-74 and again in 79) in an economy that was far more dependent on oil than is now the case.
14,300 views
D
Replying to
@deanbaker13
This was used an excuse to bash unions and eliminate many other protections that had been in place for ordinary workers, like a minimum wage that kept pace with productivity growth. I don't think these changes were in any way necessary, but the bad growth of the 70s provided an excuse anyhow.
14,300 views
Replies
No replies yet.