Post

30 replies
F
In the blue sky dataset drama, I see the pitchfork people using words such as "massive damage". I absolutely understand and support that someone has the right to control if their data is used or not to train AI systems. But what damage are they talking about?
22,390,900 views
17
C
Replying to @francoisfleuret
There is no damage from curating a dataset. If(!) someone trains a model that causes damage on yhat dataset, then people should criticize the creator of that model. bsky.app/profile/chri...
11,500 views
M
Replying to @chrisoffner3d
That's a bit broad, and completely absolves from any responsibility any data owner. It's basically just the old "guns don't kill people, people kill people" argument against gun control.
11,500 views
C
Replying to @matrig
Even if I'd entertain this (imo broken) analogy, then the person using an AI model to cause harm is the shooter, the AI model is the gun, and the dataset used to train the model is a block of carbon steel that someone turned into a gun. Are you making the steel producer responsible for the gunshot?
11,500 views
M
Replying to @chrisoffner3d
Do we really need to discuss why arguments like "guns don't kill people, people kill people" are problematic? The issues are that oversimplifying and being excessively broad ("curating datasets is never a problem & therefore should never be scrutinized")hurts the discussion by polarizing the debate.
11,500 views
Replies
M
Replying to @matrig
It's also a disservice towards those who recognized that the issue is more nuanced than "here is a datadump, do whatever you want" and took a step back to more carefully consider norms, questions about consent, personal responsibility, public perception and debate,and the societal context where that
11,500 views