S
it’s going to get weird. the USCCB is very reactionary and has a lot of money and power behind it but then a lot of under 50 priests and most of the congregations are fairly progressive on ie lgbt rights and trending positively
20,393,440 views
M
Replying to
@starshine
I keep wondering and havent seen an answer for this: if there is a dispute between the Vatican and a US bishop where the bishop is excommunicated, who changes the locks on the cathedral?
17,800 views
M
Replying to
@mtsw
Like from a legal perspective does the Pope ultimately control the property associated with the archdiocese or does the bishop?
17,800 views
B
Replying to
@mtsw
(time for me to spend way too much time learning about corporations sole)
17,800 views
B
Replying to
@brockmeyer
Seems like the simplified answer is probably "the bishop controls the temporal property of the diocese, but the pope controls who the bishop is." Interesting example of relevant legal documentation for the appointment of a new bishop below.
17,800 views
B
Replying to
@brockmeyer
(It also seems like this can vary a lot from state to state, and there are a lot of recent changes in the legal structures of the Catholic church, primarily for lawsuit related reasons...but I would bet that in general, the above principle tends to hold)
17,800 views
B
Replying to
@brockmeyer
I assume that an incumbent bishop trying to hold onto his office against the orders of the pope could take it to court, but I would guess they'd most likely fare about as well as your average sovereign citizen? I don't imagine a great appetite in US courts for deciding who the legitimate pope is...
17,800 views
B
Replying to
@brockmeyer
"is there a conceivable chain of events leading to SCOTUS deciding who the pope is?" I don't even know who I'd *ask* for that lawsplainer.
17,800 views
Replies
No replies yet.