D
Friendly reminder that block lists are LIVING DOCUMENTS. This means that people added to these later also get blocked. This may not seem a like a big deal, but it can create situations where bad actors get you to click on a list of trolls and then populate it with actual journalists later on.
9,376,750 views
H
Replying to
@duendeonfuego
at least block lists are deterministic. shinigami eyes uses a bloom filter with statistical false positives on top of the unaccountable list management
9,750 views
D
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
Interesting. I worry about list management and accountability here as well, but a deterministic process is probably better although maybe not sustainable.
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@duendeonfuego
no omg there's no excuse for it it just provides plausible deniability. completely made up problem
9,750 views
D
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
Hmmm I don't think I fully understand you here. Can you explain?
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@duendeonfuego
no need to use a probabilistic data structure like a bloom filter at all: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloom_f... bloom filters are used for optimizing lookup mechanisms but not at all as the ground truth
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
one thing that mastodon fediblock has going for it is that community admins can use instance moderation practices to make meaningful block lists. because users can always migrate their account, there is a lot of thoughtful negotiation of meaningful community relationships
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
users are also able to mute/block by instance name without having to involve an admin and admins rarely initiate a fediblock without public announcement. this means in "meta" cw threads you'll find all sorts of debate around how and where to draw these lines which can be highly democratic
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
basically one of mastodon's current problems is that gargron's technical aesthetic sensibilities are a blocker for change bc there is no spec for mastodon/misskey/gts/etc to the level of atproto, so gargron (euchen rochko, mastodon dev, "website boy") gets to stall progress without accountability
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
so fediblock as an apparatus for community negotiated relationships is really sick actually, but website boy thinks that should be enough, and he is stalling progress on safety tooling
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
so now people on mastodon are saying we need block lists like bluesky and i'm like no we need the ability to negotiate safety features with users without having to convince an apathetic engineering team who rules this implicit protocol by fiat
9,750 views
D
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
As a hypothetical, what would you propose if you were suddenly in charge of moderation and safety of this site?
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@duendeonfuego
this site like bluesky?? i don't feel qualified to answer that yet lmao i only started getting more active here a couple weeks ago. i think block lists in almost any instantiation with centralized control are really concerning, especially making them so easy to propagate decontextualized
9,750 views
H
Replying to
@hipsterelectron
i think mastodon organization into subcommunities is *super* useful and for one means that highly contextual volunteer moderation can scale!
9,750 views
D
H
Replying to
@duendeonfuego
people are working on bridges. i might be able to opt into one now
9,750 views
H
Replies
No replies yet.