Post

50 replies
L
Kim Leadbeater making extremely powerful speech opening the Assisted Dying debate. Perhaps consciously echoes language around abortion rights. Closes by saying: "The right to choose does not take away the right not to choose."
23,813,500 views
43
E
Replying to @lewisgoodall
It's a nice soundbite, but the "right not to choose" will not always be respected. Some people will be suggestible, vulnerable, in pain when they shouldn't be, and/or regarded by others as having a life not worth living. I don't think any safeguards can protect the most vulnerable from pressure.
18,500 views
J
Replying to @eagleowlsheila
So you think it is better for not choosing to be imposed? It isn't more ethical to force one group of people to suffer unnecessarily than it is to provide choice with appropriate safeguards.
18,500 views
E
Replying to @johnsays
An interesting and inappropriate way of framing it... Anyway well done for being on the winning side.
18,500 views
J
Replying to @eagleowlsheila
I don't see what's inappropriate about it. The status quo is objectively abusive to terminally ill people. We have to face up to the fact that there is a balance of harms here and that accepting the status quo does not mean there is no harm.
18,500 views
E
Replying to @johnsays
People can already choose to end their lives but no one should too that simply because palliative care is not good enough. There will be people whose stories we never hear who face the distress of making this choice rather than relying on good care. The risk of coercion can not be removed.
18,500 views
J
Replying to @eagleowlsheila
No they can't already choose to do that. At least not without going to dignitas and risking prosecution of anyone who assisted them. The rest of your post is just the complexity that I mention. For the avoidance of doubt, I of course think that the question "Is this person receiving the best...
18,500 views
Replies
J
Replying to @johnsays
possible palliative and psychological care?" should be front and centre of this.
18,500 views