Post

14 replies
I
I want the Dems to win, and I will be pragmatic about what I support, but I hope Dems don’t go populist because it’s bad for the country and the world.
13,480,420 views
9
N
Replying to @itaisher
How do you define populism? I feel like this is a word where people are operating under different definitions …
5,900 views
I
Replying to @nomadj1s
I think a basic definition is politics centered on a perceived conflict between ordinary people and the corrupt elite.
5,900 views
N
Replying to @itaisher
I see … “perceived” seems to be a key term here … is your objection that the dynamic is not real (or real enough) or that it’s ineffective? Also, would you say there’s a difference between “corrupt” and “self-interested”?
5,900 views
I
Replying to @nomadj1s
My objections are to thinking that only some people count as the real people and to the need for scapegoats which could be the elites or the establishment and also immigrants or minorities. I think populism depends on creating harmful divisions in society.
5,900 views
I
Replying to @itaisher
If a population did live under oligarchy (like say russia) would it be a populism youre opposed to the ruling class? And to correctly define that class as an enemy to a free society? I dont think i would find that unreasonable, but then we have gradations of how oligarchic the US vs. how populist
5,900 views
I
Replying to @isaiahbishop
..you want to be? I understand that politics seems foreign and wrong in ways, but the distinction between being rich and being involved in corruption is narrowing so maybe justified
5,900 views
I
Replying to @isaiahbishop
The truth is often nuanced and you have a choice of the extent to which you want to portray things in a comic book like manner. Also you can argue agains inequality and unfairness in society without leaning heavily on creating villains.
5,900 views
I
Replying to @itaisher
Sure but if such a class were to actually exist and appears to be forming, is it wrong to campaign against them? its not a comic book portrayal to notice that musk is using his resources to use govt resources to his own ends. I dont think thats debatable and its a threat to society
5,900 views
I
Replying to @isaiahbishop
A politics in which we cant be vocal about this kind of corruption seems hopeless as a democracy right?
5,900 views
I
Replying to @isaiahbishop
Musk and Trump should be called out specifically for corruption but I am not a fan of Elizabeth Warren’s more generalized stigmatization of the wealthy or AOC’s “the people vs the powerful”
5,900 views
Replies
I
Replying to @itaisher
Under the conditions of say 2000-2020 im very sympathetic to that. But we are seeing alignment among the wealthiest that they will have to engage in cronyism to remain rich, and i think its reasonable for society to impose costs on them as a class for going that route
5,900 views