Post

39 replies
H
what i’m learning is that there are a apparently good number of “anarchists” or leftists who want to abolish every kind of property except intellectual property
16,262,170 views
6
C
Replying to @hdevalence
Abolishing intellectual property while not abolishing any other property is the problem. I hope that helps.
14,650 views
S
Replying to @chainleft
I dunno, I still think it'd be a solid step forward across the board. IP is the most toxic P.
14,650 views
C
Replying to @shazow
I think physical property is more toxic.
14,650 views
S
Replying to @chainleft
Probably a matter of context, IP can impact billions of people and there's basically an infinite amount of it. Physical property impacts locals much more but doesn't scale as well.
14,650 views
C
Replying to @shazow
Think of it this way - IP is more democratic, all classes can own it (even though where you're born etc still affects it). While physical property is more bound by physical limits, where you're born, your heritage, etc affect it a lot more. More rules needed for physical property.
14,650 views
B
Replying to @chainleft
All property is physical. You could never own IP without physically having an authority, a proof/patent/tm, and violent enforcement.
14,650 views
C
Replying to @bitcoinerrorlog
ehh that's the licensing you're referring to. by that logic all data is physical because they're formed by bits stored in atoms etc
14,650 views
B
Replying to @chainleft
Yes, I am insinuating reality is physical.
14,650 views
C
Replying to @bitcoinerrorlog
Yes, and my point is that reality being physical is not the differentiating factor here in what we consider equity & democratizing factor.
14,650 views
B
Replying to @chainleft
"IP is more democratic" is logically incoherent because all property—whether physical or "intellectual"—is about exclusive control and enforcement. Ownership is inherently hierarchical and based on power, making it fundamentally incompatible with the concept of democracy.
14,650 views
Replies
C
Replying to @bitcoinerrorlog
Great - we agree on the last bit. But democracy is a spectrum, and we should also agree that while everyone is born with intellect (also not fair, to be clear), they are born with far bigger differences in physical property. Destroying the IP first and physical later is a terrible strategy.
14,650 views