Post

26 replies
S
The dumbest possible thing someone can say when reviewing media is "I enjoyed it for what it was". OH RIGHT YOU ENJOYED IT FOR WHAT IT WAS, YOU DIDN'T ENJOY IT WHILE IMAGINING IF IT WAS GOODFELLAS OR SOMETHING
15,028,780 views
1
Replies
S
Replying to @soozuk
Just gonna preempt "but Sooz, what if I was watching Goodfellas" coz that would be the sort of BlueSky-ass reply that comes rolling in of course it is.
10,100 views
P
Replying to @soozuk
"I enjoyed it for all the things it wasn't" - a writer in the guardian
10,100 views
J
Replying to @soozuk
Similarly "if it wasn't for the performance the person is actually giving, it wouldn't be as good".
10,100 views
K
Replying to @soozuk
That's not what that means lol
10,100 views
O
Replying to @soozuk
I think it's more about getting something else that isn't as good as your expectations but good enough. Like expecting a full sized chocolate bar and getting a couple mini ones instead. It didn't quite add up to your expectations but you still got chocolate.
10,100 views
G
Replying to @soozuk
Good one!
10,100 views
N
Replying to @soozuk
I enjoyed this post for what it was (has it died?)
10,100 views
S
Replying to @soozuk
There what it was and then there’s what it was supposed to be.
10,100 views
S
Replying to @soozuk
Totally, it feels adjacent to the concept of "guilty pleasures". It's just a sly way of saying "I like this thing but I think I'm too good for the genre". Guy, just like what you like, be honest and be free - you ain't gonna get kicked out of Manly Club for enjoying a Nora Ephron
10,100 views
S
Replying to @soozuk
eh makes sense, that is how i enjoy The Holiday, ie. for what it is, a piece of shit where every character is terrible, whereas if i was watching it objectively as a christmas rom-com i wouldn't enjoy it at all, because it is a piece of shit and every character is terrible. expectation management x
10,100 views
B
Replying to @soozuk
idk.. have u met a sports anime fan? they absolutely enjoy a show by watching 80% in their imagination
10,100 views
J
Replying to @soozuk
But Sooz, I haven't seen Goodfellas 🫣
10,100 views
A
Replying to @soozuk
But I always rate my movies by how many Goodfellas I give it. Mrs. Doubtfire is 4.5 Goodfellas.
10,100 views
P
Replying to @soozuk
So, back to endlessly referencing other films then? This movie is like if Predator 2 fucked Howard the Duck and the son fucked Eyes Wide Shut and they had a baby. Know what I mean?
10,100 views