Post

129 replies
A
i guess this just comes back to my problems with punk in general. it just sounds like high schoolers who haven't learned how to play their instruments well or write a compelling song yet
23,941,870 views
46
E
Replying to @angelic
tbh your opinions on punk are uninformed and inaccurate. ignorant even. in fact they are offensive to me as a general music enjoyer and guitarist myself bcs you have put so little effort into forming your opinion
46,150 views
A
Replying to @eldenslut
alright, who do i need to listen to to be proven wrong ? what should i be listening for when i listen to punk ? what about my opinion seems uninformed ? i'm happy to learn and be proven wrong but i've listened to a fair amount of punk in my time
46,150 views
E
Replying to @angelic
but nuvolascura is the one that blew my mind when i heard them. mahria too. lord snow was like if coke is music. and frail body is nerdy shit
46,150 views
A
Replying to @eldenslut
spun some tracks from nuvolascura and mahria and those were both good, better than a lot of what i've heard but also like. they feel pretty far from most punk ? i think both of them are screamo, which seems to be is kind of like post-post-punk you're getting pretty far removed here
46,150 views
E
Replying to @angelic
no thats punk now too. like those bands call (or called) themselves punks, their audience called them punks, other punk bands called them punks. there is infighting sure but its mostly misogynists who are now being shoved out of scene who will only argue they arent punk
46,150 views
E
Replying to @eldenslut
i mean i just saw frail body at a a vfw and they were playing with like saltwound which is the type of hardcore i really dont like but its all punk. just completely different styles.
46,150 views
A
Replying to @eldenslut
yeah i suppose that's not fair when u can do the same thing with metal and how far it's come from its inception and honestly i never fully believed that there were Zero Punk Bands that made musically interesting music just that that's not a part of punk's core ethos
46,150 views
E
Replying to @angelic
idk if theres a single punk ethos anymore. it really seems split and all i can say is that i belong to a scene full of communists who want to make more artistic music & performances and organize to end capitalism through our music
46,150 views
A
Replying to @eldenslut
see that's something that's also rubbed me the wrong way about most punk forgive me if this is not a charitable read but punk seems to see the music as a means for a message whereas a lot of the music i think is Best sees the music as a means for Music
46,150 views
E
Replying to @angelic
historically youre right but that is changing now. its not just about the message, but about the material support necessary for music and a music scene to even be possible.
46,150 views
E
Replying to @eldenslut
right now the biggest concern of my local scene is making new DIY venues (diy meaning anti-capitalist, not controlled by a landlord). right now we only have one, which is an incredibly impressive feat. cities like austin or nashville lack the space we have here.
46,150 views
A
Replying to @eldenslut
i suppose that i've never really felt like a part of a music scene, even as a huge metalhead that goes to shows a ton. those kinds of things never even cross my mind when it comes to thinking about or making music
46,150 views
Replies
E
Replying to @angelic
yeah metal has been commercialized a lot. there are some metal bands who operate in the scene though. honestly ppl call them punk tho no one really cares anymore
46,150 views