H
It's not free market principles driving privatisation. It's pure greed. People don't choose which ambulance to take, which train provider they need, or whose electricity they prefer. We use what we need, when we need it. Water is water.
12,121,570 views
H
Replying to
@harryeccles
I can’t let that go Harry! With the right regulation (which we often haven’t) private ownership can lead to higher investment and, importantly & part of the original drive for privatisation, that investment is not part of public borrowing leaving that funding source for other things like hospitals
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@hedgert
Are you suggesting that centralised money through schemes such as bailouts, quantative easing, outsourced contracts etc isn't sustaining private wealth?
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@harryeccles
No I agree those actions play a role - but your original post suggests that all private wealth is sourced from the public sector and I don’t think there’s any basis for that. And of course even when there are interventions like those you mention much of funding is from racing private income
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@hedgert
Money comes from central banks. People are born in public hospitals and trained in public school, people use public roads paid for from the public purse. Then theres state bailouts and financing. The extent to which private money comes from the state in neoliberal societies is sickening.
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@harryeccles
Money doesn’t come from central Banks. Central banks print currency and sometimes (on government instruction) create money (and inflation) by printing more than they should. But what the public sector spends comes from tax and borrowing - and who does the government borrow from - the private sector
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@hedgert
till those private firms/banks need bailing out? The fact is, it's often socialism for the rich, and austerity for the rest of us.
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@harryeccles
And government borrowing is either through bonds or QE. Both of which sees private equity benefit from the state
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@harryeccles
I don’t think we’re going to agree on this Harry - but I hear your perspective. In my view the public sector comes from the private sector and from private enterprise. We choose to pool private enterprise for the public good; but it doesn’t come from the public sector in the first place.
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@hedgert
Interesting theory, that would mean that the private sector came before the state! I'm not sure that's historically accurate! Perhaps it's an irrelevant question which came first. That taxation and public are being misappropriated, and whilst we fave austerity, private wealth gets a blank cheque
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@harryeccles
I think that’s very clearly the case. Look back in history to city states and to feudal systems where to get power a state figure had to gain the support of local (private) landowners to raise money and soldiers.
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@hedgert
And further back still? What did we have before money/currency. We had private individuals agreeing to exchange items or labour with each other. Absolutely no state involved there.
7,650 views
H
Replying to
@hedgert
I think we are conflating many different threads here. I am a libertarian so not pro big state. However, private sector leaching of monopolised sectors and the state is not free or fair.
7,650 views
Replies
No replies yet.