G
Can I ask your stance on assistive AI? Specifically, if, how and why they should/shouldn't might be applicable to everything in this post? If you are not in favour, consider my possible points moot and the topic closed forever.
8,899,390 views
A
Replying to
@greenlens
I'm at best ambivalent on the advantages of AI. It's got very high error rates in important matters, and relies upon industrial scale theft and horrendous environmental damage. If it improves to overcome this, individuals will still want to stay ahead of their peers with the same tools.
5,550 views
G
Replying to
@adstanley
I have very high error rates myself 😄 Of critical importance, as in most things are skills but skilful use of language and critical thinking are paramount, it is a Large Language Model. Some of the most challenging and fruitful conversations I've had have been through careful tool use.
5,550 views
G
Replying to
@greenlens
I'm loathe to attempt to further engage in a conversation that might not be for you, can you advise please?
5,550 views
A
Replying to
@greenlens
Happy to engage, but we seem to be in fundamentally different camps. If AI was my employee, I'd fire them. Fast is great, but expensive, stupid, doesn't learn from mistakes, and opaque reasoning is unacceptable.
5,550 views
G
Replying to
@adstanley
Okay, different camps for now I hope. I don't think any of us really want folks fired, it's coming through no fault of theirs but different convo. It automates, the history of industry is automation, cheaper faster now! It can augment too though, to real and considerable effect, the potential of
5,550 views
G
Replying to
@greenlens
the employee to achieve the aims of the employer. Now I hate that argument tbc but it is correct and the why of my hate is, again, another convo.
5,550 views
A
Replying to
@greenlens
I don't believe that AI replaces human intellect in any meaningful way. If it did, I think it would be useful to have intellectual skills to be competitive in the changed work force. For the moment, it's gambling with algorithms, which is a pitiful shadow of human creative/ intellectual potential
5,550 views
Replies
G
Replying to
@adstanley
Augments. Do we apply then the precaution principle in favour of training or in favour of/reaction to(?) a maybe fearful, possibly gut, reaction? I'm arguing that it has potential, not human, does that matter? Microsoft Word springs to mind. It a 'you need it in the office environment kinda deal.
5,550 views