E
It's the singing and dancing, but... This is the only way I can explain it: NIGHTS OF CALABRIA is a film with a lot of dark themes. It could have been adapted as a play or an opera without a ton of changes to the book but to be a musical it had to become Sweet Charity.
15,694,360 views
E
Replying to
@edenawrites
Gypsy, Cabaret, Chicago---dark as they are for musicals, would have to get much grittier to occupy a comparable place in the world of straight plays or opera. But what's clear overall is that we have to get united on what we mean by "corny."
5,200 views
E
Replying to
@edenawrites
Point taken but I still don’t agree that makes them corny. Now we’re getting into degrees of corn — a quality for which there isn’t a universally accepted definition to begin with, as this thread seems to demonstrate.
5,200 views
S
Replying to
@evincentelli
if I’d known we’d still be talking about it 24 hours later I might have defined my terms better, but then so many of the complaints against LMM kind of boil down to vibes, which were for a while perhaps better than they should have been and are now unaccountably worse
5,200 views
E
Replying to
@samadams
I think I can tell you the moment his stock dropped: when Hillary Clinton quoted him at the end of her acceptance speech for her nomination. I cannot describe the feeling of pure yikes that went through my body for both of them. 1/
5,200 views
E
Replying to
@edenawrites
But that was the moment he stopped being a Latino upstart challenging a very white theatrical establishment, to becoming a firm part of the establishment. After that, he became inescapable but no other minority voices followed through the door that he ostensibly kicked open --- oh and Trump won. 2/
5,200 views
E
Replying to
@edenawrites
What Hamilton meant in 2009 when it was an idea shared by LMM in a brand new Obama White House, was gone when 45 took office. The elder millennial wisdom of the representation leading in a straight line to progress, well all that failed. After that people re-examined how they felt about the work. 3/
5,200 views
E
Replying to
@edenawrites
(It's no coincidence that Obama's legacy was getting another look around the same time.) Now good progressives didn't want LMM they wanted Kendrick Lamar. They wanted authenticity and voices that would challenge systems, not compromise with them. B/c the MAGA folks weren't polite and they won 4/
5,200 views
Replies
E
Replying to
@edenawrites
Now anything that resembles that kind of compromise with the establishment, well the kindest word we have for it is corny. 5/5
5,200 views