A
i guess this just comes back to my problems with punk in general. it just sounds like high schoolers who haven't learned how to play their instruments well or write a compelling song yet
23,941,870 views
I
Replying to
@angelic
Part of the punk movement was the idea that anyone could be in a punk band. Certainly some prominent punks like Sid Vicious were more about attitude than chops, but most of the major punk acts were musically talented and were choosing to play simply as a statement.
46,150 views
I
Replying to
@isabellesogay
The first wave of punks also created post punk and new wave as they diversified their musical approaches. Wire went from punk to post punk in three albums. The Clash were one of the most musically adventurous bands in the western world by 1979. Johnny Rotten forms Public Image, Ltd.
46,150 views
N
Replying to
@isabellesogay
a lot of what ppl say to talk shit about punk rock is actually just talking shit about the kinks, but also the kinks invented metal too, sorry not sorry
46,150 views
I
Replying to
@nacl
I have and always will maintain that Black Sabbath invented heavy metal, as the first hand to combine the sound of metal with the imagery that typifies the genre. There are songs before Sabbath’s first album that point the way to metal but the genre exists as it does because of Sabbath.
46,150 views
E
Replying to
@isabellesogay
honestly idk what to make of metal. its like it became entirely different immediately sometime in the mid 2000s
46,150 views
N
Replying to
@eldenslut
i like maudlin the well and ngl i think modern metal is too technical like it's just impressive for the sake of it doesnt make me feel anything like at all. it's just piano music with guitars.
46,150 views
A
Replying to
@nacl
i hate ppl positing technicality and emotion as two ends of a spectrum straight up thats a skill issue
46,150 views
N
Replying to
@angelic
no no not two ends of a spectrum but damn i think one extreme is worse than the other
46,150 views
N
Replying to
@nacl
i would rather if there is a choice to listen to a bunch of children who dont understand how to play their instruments but have strong feelings about girls than accomplished concert performers. idk why not just do something impressive on a computer.
46,150 views
N
Replying to
@nacl
the whole point of a guitar is that idiots can play guitar and that's why guitarists arent musicians. same goes even more for electric guitar, it's guitar for idiots too idiot to play guitar. but that rules. give it to some kids with gender dysphoria and substance abuse issues, they always cook.
46,150 views
A
Replying to
@nacl
its like youre writing posts expressly and scientifically designed to piss me off
46,150 views
N
Replying to
@angelic
i LOVE to troll but i swear i am it saying this to you just to be contrarian i do genuinely believe this, i am just like this
46,150 views
N
B
Replying to
@nacl
i think what you're saying is that there are performative guitar players, call them Politically Guitar-players, who learn 12 songs to play for girls and they are different from Guitarists, who have devoted their lives to studying the Way of the Axe
46,150 views
A
J
Replying to
@angelic
Hey it’s me juli, punk was a reaction to prog and metal, a democratizing force. I am now gesturing toward Tom Verlaine and Carrie Brownstein to note the technicality that never left, just changed in application. Consider the skill of playing one note in many different ways
46,150 views
A
Replying to
@juli
i mean that explains a lot, punk is a direct reaction to and rejection of the genres i love most
46,150 views
B
Replying to
@angelic
it wasn't just a reaction to those genres tho, like to the overproduction of music in general. iirc Hotel California the record was also one of the inspirations for the reaction
46,150 views
A
Replying to
@baeddel
i mean i dont like the eagles in general but hotel california is an amazing song and i value high production quality a lot this is what i mean when i say the punk ethos is the antithesis of everything i stand for musically
46,150 views
B
Replying to
@angelic
i honestly felt the same way for a long time too but like i don't think the punk ethos is really that cohesive, like yeah it happened in part because of those musics but that was also 50 years ago and so much has happened since.
46,150 views
B
Replying to
@baeddel
also re: your actual stance, i always find it difficult to balance what i think is good, or high, production value with not sounding too "slick" (is what my dad called it). but high production value isnt automatically synonymous with commercial production value.
46,150 views
J
Replying to
@baeddel
remain in light is one of the best produced records ~ever~ and it is arguably punk. can we all agree on Eno? man was prog AND punk (there is no way krystal agrees on Eno)
46,150 views
A
Replying to
@juli
honestly ive never rly listened to him i rarely listen to anything pre-2000 anymore
46,150 views
Replies
J
Replying to
@angelic
well, helpfully, eno recorded tons in the 70s and 80s. also he produced all the good u2 albums, one time bono said he was gonna be the new ian curtis after ian curtis died, it is wild to connect literally u2 to punk rock but yeah, they make punk with lots of pedals it rules
46,150 views
J
Replying to
@angelic
anyways if u wanna hear something truly great, big recommends on Another Green World by Eno
46,150 views