Post

75 replies
S
While I don't feel as negatively about the new "hotness" setting as some do, I agree it's potentially manipulatable by bad actors and don't think it should be the default, which it currently is. I'd go into my settings and change it (I use "Newest Replies First" as my default).
20,970,250 views
34
Replies
J
Replying to @scalzi
I just did this five minutes ago. I don’t like it either.
27,250 views
A
Replying to @scalzi
I reckon most of the viscerally negative reaction to it is just people seeing that it has Twitter Flavour to it and immediately having that gut-sinking assumption that its going to produce a similar result
27,250 views
I
Replying to @scalzi
I'm on that posters roulette for now, we shall see if I change to some other option down the road 😀The default could maybe be better, but I do like the amount of options there are right now.
27,250 views
E
Replying to @scalzi
Oh good. Cuz now I look at time been on to get newest.
27,250 views
M
Replying to @scalzi
I read about the new hotness feature and did not care, because I am not going to use it. And then I realized that my feeds are weird because it is set as the default? Not cool, bsky.
27,250 views
B
Replying to @scalzi
Who gets to decide if we're hot or not? What if I'm just a little bloated that day? 😳
27,250 views
S
Replying to @scalzi
My default was still listed as newest.
27,250 views
H
Replying to @scalzi
Thanks John. That information was super helpful. I've always had an issue with rarely seeing the most recent posts.
27,250 views
N
Replying to @scalzi
I think it depends on the kind of account the OP is. If it's someone like yourself, with thousands of followers and a large number of replies to a given post, then having a crowd-curated "top 10" list keeps things manageable. If it's an IRL friend, then I want chronological threading.
27,250 views
L
Replying to @scalzi
agreed! & so happy it’s visible & that we have a choice 🙏
27,250 views
A
Replying to @scalzi
I’m all for choice, but making it the default feels like enshittification
27,250 views
M
Replying to @scalzi
No hotness for me.
27,250 views
O
Replying to @scalzi
Easy for brigaders to collectively pump up a hate filled reply to raise its visibility, maybe the algorithm needs a differential and integral term to not react too quickly to sudden brigades
27,250 views
S
Replying to @scalzi
This. I agree it shouldn’t be default either, I did the same and moved to newest first.
27,250 views
P
Replying to @scalzi
IIRC, Facebook had chronological posts as the default for a long time, then switched to an algorithm and chronological became harder and harder to find and switch back to. Really hoping that doesn't happen here.
27,250 views
C
Replying to @scalzi
I feel negatively about my settings being changed behind my back. I'd have never known without your above note. Thanks!
27,250 views
M
Replying to @scalzi
I do feel very negatively. It's a classic rage-baiting tactic, for which Meta is famous.
27,250 views
J
Replying to @scalzi
Mine still had its defaults after the update. Weird.
27,250 views
C
Replying to @scalzi
Where does it say that hotness is a default? Is that a presumption? Is an opinion being read as policy?
27,250 views
R
Replying to @scalzi
Thanks for the tip!
27,250 views
F
Replying to @scalzi
Thanks for bringing this to my (and everyone's) attention.
27,250 views
J
Replying to @scalzi
While I don’t personally like this feature, I’m confident that most people will want it, and it’s unfortunately essential for the growth of Bluesky.
27,250 views
H
Replying to @scalzi
Thank you for making this known. I wouldn’t have been aware without your post.
27,250 views
P
Replying to @scalzi
I went with oldest first cause I don't want the relative position of replies to change so I can find them again more really if I need to.
27,250 views
D
Replying to @scalzi
I hope they listen to people about it.
27,250 views
B
Replying to @scalzi
That explains why replies appeared to be out of order.
27,250 views
D
Replying to @scalzi
this is default? gross, thanks for letting me know
27,250 views
J
Replying to @scalzi
Thanks for the heads up, adjusted. I am trying the experimental threaded view now
27,250 views
D
Replying to @scalzi
Oof. Yeah, that's a misstep. Come on, @support.bsky.team, add the feature without making it the default. Changing defaults without notice makes for a poor user experience.
27,250 views
P
Replying to @scalzi
@bsky.app what I find particularly antisocial about this change is that when I joined I meticulously looked at all the settings and set them the way I wanted. Even if I left this one as the default at the time, changing it to the new default is what I expect from Microsoft, ie a total dick move.
27,250 views
E
Replying to @scalzi
Thanks for mentioning this. I’d have been annoyed by it and assumed it wasn’t changeable.
27,250 views
M
Replying to @scalzi
📌
27,250 views
B
Replying to @scalzi
Thanks for mentioning this. I saw it was a new thing, but am displeaaed it was made the default when I already had a non-default setting. 😠 I've changed it back now.
27,250 views
N
Replying to @scalzi
Boo
27,250 views
D
Replying to @scalzi
As long as the choice exists I'm happy. As a default specifically. I'm tired of having to tell FB to out group posts in actual order every time I visit one.
27,250 views
P
Replying to @scalzi
I had been wondering why my feed looked so weird. Thanks for posting this. Now back to Newest
27,250 views
C
Replying to @scalzi
Thank you.
27,250 views
P
Replying to @scalzi
Thank you for the tip!
27,250 views
L
Replying to @scalzi
Random actually looks interesting. As an intelligence test. 🤣
27,250 views
L
Replying to @scalzi
On my phone, I use the app, but on my iPad I read bsky in a browser. I don’t see the “hotness” option when I go to th appropriate spot in my settings. Does that mean I’m not interacting with the newest version via the browser? (Seems like that would be near the front of a roll-out?)
27,250 views
P
Replying to @scalzi
Didn’t know that was the default now! Sorted that, thank you for this info.
27,250 views
C
Replying to @scalzi
Thanks, I've changed the setting from 'hotness' (really not a good name for it IMO!) to 'newest replies first'. I'd much prefer that to be the default but at least we can change it individually.
27,250 views