Batesv45

15 posts
B

Batesv45

@batesv45
Imported Bluesky account. Main topic: general. Original handle: batesv45.bsky.social.
0 Following
0 Followers
B
Replying to @reggiedunlop
"Conflict of interest for the Department." Not sure I disagree with you there. But like any entity, the Department acts through individuals. I'm sure Katyal didn't want to allude specifically to Rule 1.7 in drafting.
50,350 views
B
Replying to @reggiedunlop
The professional rules that govern attorneys define what a conflict of interest is. Here's the DC version of Rule of Professional Conduct 1.7, which applies to DOJ attorneys admitted in DC: www.dcbar.org/for-lawyers/...
50,350 views
B
Replying to @paulrosenberg
I'm not wild about it. But without a statute, it may be the best we can do. I'm not one who thinks that the Executive is necessarily unitary (in part because the Federal Reserve's independence is a good thing). But until SCOTUS refutes the Thomas concurrence, that argument is out there.
50,350 views
B
Replying to @batesv45
But of course no one at DOJ wanted to say that. So the Trump-campaign announcement became the casus specialis advocati. IIRC, the reason for the appointment was left to the public to determine--and everyone leapt to the campaign-announcement conclusion. www.justice.gov/opa/gallery/....
50,350 views
B
Replying to @paulrosenberg
Exactly. The Trump announcement was a convenient hook. The real conflict that DOJ had--and again, I'm not sure it was fully managed or manageable--was with the presidency and with the sitting president, Biden.
50,350 views
B
Replying to @reggiedunlop
See my post above about conflicts with the institutional interests of the presidency and whoever the sitting president is. To argue, as the SCO did to SCOTUS, that the president lacks immunity, is to be conflicted with the sitting president (Biden) as well as the defendant at issue (Trump).
50,350 views
B
Replying to @batesv45
would present a conflict of interest for the Department or other extraordinary circumstances; and (b) That under the circumstances, it would be in the public interest to appoint an outside Special Counsel to assume responsibility for the matter.
50,350 views
B
Replying to @batesv45
when he or she determines that criminal investigation of a person or matter is warranted and— (a) That investigation or prosecution of that person or matter by a United States Attorney's Office or litigating Division of the Department of Justice
50,350 views
B
Replying to @batesv45
4. and here's the text. Let us know which part you don't think is satisfied? § 600.1 Grounds for appointing a Special Counsel. The Attorney General, or in cases in which the Attorney General is recused, the Acting Attorney General, will appoint a Special Counsel
50,350 views
B
Replying to @batesv45
3. and I've cited them in a SCOTUS filing:
50,350 views
B
Replying to @reggiedunlop
1. how? 2. yes, I do know. In part because Neal Katyal keeps telling us he wrote them.
50,350 views
B
Replying to @batesv45
To be clear, I'm not confident the SCO is a great solution to that conflict. The SCO is still part of the Executive Branch, and as we've seen from recent filings, regulations require it to consult with the rest of DOJ. So the SCO is still the Executive, which means (if unitary) the President.
50,350 views
B
Replying to @reggiedunlop
Of course there was a basis to appoint a special counsel in 2021. As we've seen from the immunity case, any prosecution of Trump requires the prosecutor to make arguments that are not in the interests of the presidency as an institution or of the sitting president (whoever that is).
50,350 views
B
Replying to @batesv45
DOJ moved to dismiss in early 2021, at the beginning of Garland's tenure. On appeal to the 2d Circuit, however, DOJ maintained its position. So . . . DOJ, I told you so.
50,350 views
B
Replying to @paulrosenberg
Violating the corporate-neutrality doctrine, Garland's DOJ also moved to dismiss an early effort to hold Trump to account for Jan. 6: my derivative action o/b/o the United States. Which I filed on Jan. 19, 2021, when DOJ was conflicted. And here we are again. www.supremecourt.gov/search.aspx?...
50,350 views