Closdeph

7 posts
C

Closdeph

@closdeph
Imported Bluesky account. Main topic: general. Original handle: closdeph.bsky.social.
0 Following
0 Followers
C
Replying to @closdeph
Depending on what is meant by "not agreeing with (sex) work abolition" though
6,950 views
C
Replying to @jessothomson
I would think that makes sense. I think there is a good chance I'm just misinterpreting stuff, especially wrt trans womanhood as a *thing*
6,950 views
C
Replying to @julieofthespiri
I guess I have my own issues with the dismissiveness "identity" and "identitarianism" is treated with usually, compared to its relative importance in making more trans women i.e. hurting patriarchy as a hierarchy at the seams, but it's all pretty tangential to the main point here. Broadly I agree !
6,950 views
C
Replying to @closdeph
I really don't want to undermine the points of the c4ss piece cause it all seems valid as a critique of Gill-Peterson's stuff, but I, like I said, don't think it's completely compatible as is with trans womanhood as describes by the Talia piece as I understand it - but again mb I'm wrong
6,950 views
C
Replying to @closdeph
So for example when we hear in the c4ss piece that trans women are sometimes hostile to sex work as a practice, there are two things to think, either their material conditions are such that such an hostility is justified, or "oh they have their brands of swerfs"; I would favor the second explanation
6,950 views
C
Replying to @jessothomson
Again I might be wrong, but it seems that Talia Bhatt's piece advocates for the existence of a sort of general transfem experience that somewhat transcends particular cultures, whereas the c4ss piece places a lot of emphasis on the travesti experience as a particular culturally contingent thing
6,950 views