B
There is something at the heart of this story that doesn’t add up, legally speaking. Quick fraud lecture for y’all. 🧵
22,088,110 views
B
Replying to
@barristersecret
Fraud by false representation requires the dishonest making of a false statement, intending to make a gain for oneself or another, or a loss to another. (Section 2 of the Fraud Act 2006)
48,950 views
B
Replying to
@barristersecret
Louise Haigh’s statement asserts unambiguously that she did not act dishonestly, and implies that she did not intend to make a gain for herself. If this is correct, she should never have been advised to plead guilty.
48,950 views
B
Replying to
@barristersecret
Now, sometimes people receive bad advice. But this is really basic law. As in, a first-year law student would point out that, on Ms Haigh’s instructions, she has a defence. And on the evidential picture she offers, it sounds like a strong defence. So why would a solicitor advise pleading guilty?
48,950 views
B
Replying to
@barristersecret
Three possibilities: 1) Gross professional negligence by the solicitor. Or 2) She admitted her guilt - i.e dishonest intent - to her solicitor. Or 3) She denied dishonesty to her solicitor, but the evidence was so strong that she was advised she would lose a trial, and chose to plead guilty.
48,950 views
B
Replying to
@barristersecret
There’s another peculiarity. Not only has, apparently, the solicitor advised her to admit an offence which she insists she hasn’t committed, but she says that the magistrates went on to sentence her - *while acknowledging that she hadn’t been dishonest*. This should never happen.
48,950 views
B
Replying to
@barristersecret
If a defendant’s plea is “equivocal” - i.e. if they plead guilty but tell the court “I didn’t actually do this”, the court should not agree to sentence. Now again, it is far from unheard of for magistrates’ courts to make errors. But it’s another oddity in this story.
48,950 views
B
Replying to
@barristersecret
Either Louise Haigh is the victim of a miscarriage of justice caused by multiple failings in the justice system (which is of course entirely possible). Or, she has been less than truthful about what really happened. Either way, it sounds like a story which has some way to run yet.
48,950 views
Replies
C
Replying to
@barristersecret
Always appreciate your analysis SB. Enjoyed your last three books and looking forward to any possible fourth.
48,950 views
P
Replying to
@barristersecret
It was just such a weird story from the get-go. I'm no expert in law, but I'd have thought anyone with a client who made an honest mistake would want them to put the record straight, not to respond to everything with 'No comment'.
48,950 views
G
Replying to
@barristersecret
That time was pretty strange. At that time I had two work phones plus my own. With all the other stuff going on(60+hour weeks) I can understand confusion, but I would agree there is more to shake out here. But I don’t think it should be a witchhunt for something that is relatively trivial.
48,950 views
M
Replying to
@barristersecret
All very odd- especially to resurface after all this time when it should cast no shadow by this stage. But was it just an excuse to give her the push?
48,950 views
C
Replying to
@barristersecret
Alternatively, she was a dumb young person that made bad choices. That weren't that awful, just illegal
48,950 views
A
Replying to
@barristersecret
OR It could just be another rw press pile-on aimed at yet another Labour female politician. Mountain, molehill, meh.
48,950 views
P
Replying to
@barristersecret
You’d think that Starmer would be aware of this stuff - which just makes things all the more peculiar?
48,950 views
R
Replying to
@barristersecret
Does a 'Newton' hearing take place at a magistrates court?
48,950 views
H
Replying to
@barristersecret
This is why I like social media, I can follow a multitude of experts providing opinions and insights into things I know little about. Thank you for this overview, I’ve missed these.
48,950 views
C
Replying to
@barristersecret
When I applied for my current job, there were extensive background checks because we deal with sensitive Govt information. Why don't MPs have to go through such a process? Doing something like this would ensure there's no skeletons coming out of closets at a later date.
48,950 views
R
Replying to
@barristersecret
Are old court records accessible? Ie would the discussion in court, rather than just the verdict, be available?
48,950 views
G
R
Replying to
@barristersecret
Thanks SB, I had a feeling that I wasn't hearing the full truth! Thanks for pinning it down.
48,950 views
J
Replying to
@barristersecret
I read that Keir Starmer was unhappy with the balance of evidence so moved quickly against Haigh. He’s more qualified than most!
48,950 views
F
Replying to
@barristersecret
The no reply interview makes me think she has been less than truthful
48,950 views
B
Replying to
@barristersecret
Why wouldn't the police just accept a caution? Does this mean that the crown prosecution service were involved?
48,950 views
G
Replying to
@barristersecret
I'm expecting to see her being interviewed on the green outside parliament while every move, gesture or gesticulating she makes will be accompanied by a handful of smartphones falling out of her trench coat and clattering onto the floor.
48,950 views
R
Replying to
@barristersecret
Another question: who would know all the details of this case to leak to The Times..?
48,950 views
J
Replying to
@barristersecret
I wondered if the charge wasn’t fraud, but making a false statement - just sloppy language in the press. If so, then her stated facts about the phone could be true, while still being guilty of something else. It also might be one that is appropriately marked by a discharge, with no fine.
48,950 views
L
C
Replying to
@barristersecret
I can accept a less than stellar police station rep making the error of advising no reply when the client has an innocent account, but advising a guilty plea at court in the face of a denial of an essential ingredient of the offence, nope.
48,950 views
D
Replying to
@barristersecret
And Starmer, being a lawyer, would be thinking along your lines too. He's not stupid and I doubt he likes to be treated as such.
48,950 views
G
Replying to
@barristersecret
Could it be she pleaded guilty because she could not afford the cost of à trial? That’s another form of miscarriage of justice.
48,950 views
N
Replying to
@barristersecret
If work issued a new phone, the original sim would have been cancelled, so to make a call with the first phone would have required swapping in a new sim card. Did she give it to someone else as a gift after she found it? Or make an insurance claim for it?
48,950 views
P
B
M