Post

51 replies
J
I've never considered TTRPGs to be about storytelling. At least in my mind, that suggests something way more deliberate than the fucking around, finding out thing happening at our table. We're following the characters, seeing what happens and riffing off of that. There's no aim to "tell a story".
21,851,530 views
35
J
Replying to @johannohr
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding this, but to me, playing these games are as much storytelling as my everyday life is. I'm just doing stuff until I'm not, it's not curated for some audience.
18,850 views
Replies
A
Replying to @johannohr
I think there lots of good stories in every day life. A lot can be garnered from "I made this weirdo fuck and we're gonna see how they handle this situation". Going in with the goal of "making a story" does totally feel like turning fun stupid make believe time into content tho.
18,850 views
A
Replying to @johannohr
I think they’re both fun ways of looking at it, I think to not try and tell a story would disappoint a lot of groups, but trying to do so without leaving space for fucking around always sucks
18,850 views
J
Replying to @johannohr
This has always been my position! We can make stories about the events in a roleplaying game the same way we make stories about events in our lives, but going through them is not storytelling per se. For me, roleplaying is about direct experience, not meta-level storycrafting.
18,850 views
A
Replying to @johannohr
Do you not ever tell people about events in your everyday life? Like the night you spent naked up a tree or when you went out for a swift pint but ended up at a concert 50 miles away? Those are the stories of your everyday life, RPGs just allow you to create those stories every time you play
18,850 views
E
Replying to @johannohr
I think it becomes a story in hindsight. Whether it's compelling (or even coherent) depends on the group. But playing specifically to tell a story leaves out important stuff like playing WITH others and the all-important fucking around and finding out.
18,850 views
R
Replying to @johannohr
I sound like a broken clock on this topic but it's overdue for TTRPG enthusiasts, especially who want to comment on the Hobby, to understand there are various, often contradicting, forms of TTRPG.
18,850 views
L
Replying to @johannohr
From understanding/interpretation/implementation of these sorts of discussions, I absolutely agree with this sentiment here. Folks come together to play a game, take on a role of some sort and (will often) work together. Those memories, feelings etc. do become a story of in itself which can, but...
18,850 views
H
Replying to @johannohr
Is the story the events happening or is it the retelling of the events that happened? Seems to be the issue. If raiding the goblin lair causes a series of entertaining consequences does that count as telling a story as it happens or only once the ending comes about and it becomes a discreet thing?
18,850 views