Post

51 replies
J
I've never considered TTRPGs to be about storytelling. At least in my mind, that suggests something way more deliberate than the fucking around, finding out thing happening at our table. We're following the characters, seeing what happens and riffing off of that. There's no aim to "tell a story".
21,851,530 views
35
Replies
J
Replying to @johannohr
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding this, but to me, playing these games are as much storytelling as my everyday life is. I'm just doing stuff until I'm not, it's not curated for some audience.
18,850 views
J
Replying to @johannohr
I've always thought that the new tendency within groups to want to 'tell a story' comes from the explosion of Actual Plays, where they kind of have to in order to be worth a listen. Many players first exposure to TTRPGs now comes from curated stories told with the aid of some dice.
18,850 views
P
Replying to @johannohr
This leads to such a weird barrier when talking about ttrpgs, and unneeded friction between different styles. There is no common baseline, and it is hard to communicate the expectations in online discussions.
18,850 views
S
Replying to @johannohr
My year long dnd 5e campaign is coming to an end soon and the "story" was basically everything that unfolded naturally from the setup I made on day one. I feel like if I wrote it all down it'd make a good read but definitely wasn't intended or planned. And I like it that way!
18,850 views
A
Replying to @johannohr
Yeah I tend to think about the actual play as interacting with a fiction, but I do want the things we do and the things that happen in that fiction to be interesting, and when they do, your reflective consciousness processing it at the time, your recollection later, & your retelling, those are story
18,850 views
H
Replying to @johannohr
I recently introduced the 5-room dungeon to my game design teacher and his immediate remark was how it resembles the hero's journey. My definition for a story is "a series of events we ascribe meaning to". The storytelling was always there, you just have to know what to look for.
18,850 views
G
Replying to @johannohr
My original group played AD&D, First Edition Warhammer Fantasy Role-Play many years ago. We were very much a role-play heavy group. The games we were playing had a definite narrative feel. I would describe our games as storytelling.
18,850 views
A
Replying to @johannohr
I would say that 'finding out' and the 'riffing' are both fundamental units of storytelling. But I also agree that there's many different modes of ttrpg and 'fuck around and find out' is a useful model (and an alternative/synonym to apocalypse world et al's 'play to find out')
18,850 views
M
Replying to @johannohr
This has been on my mind of late (I’m a game designer but also a writer). I don’t gel with the hero’s journey concept, heavily defined three act structures, or the ‘7 plots’. Maybe it’s why I prefer games where story emerges instead, and stuff like the 5 room dungeon doesn’t appeal to me.
18,850 views
K
Replying to @johannohr
Maybe this has to do with modern conceptions of "Quality" wrt stories. I know that when I read old myths, they sound a lot more like "and then something random and silly happened", which jives more with your TTRPG purpose/experience. It's all story. Some stories are less full of themselves.
18,850 views
R
Replying to @johannohr
The stories that get told are just the memories after a game finishes, the funny jokes or the badass clutch scene or someone doing something so stupid it works. Actual plays set the standard for cohesive narrative but the only goal a game constantly has no matter what is to be "fun".
18,850 views
A
Replying to @johannohr
It's definitely a weird grey area, and I like to think about it more from an 'emergent story' angle. We are (technically) telling a story, but that story is naturally coming out from the interactions of the people running the game and the game system itself.
18,850 views
G
Replying to @johannohr
I feel that there are a lot of things that affect what might be a useful paradigm for how we play TTRPGs. System, group preferences, GM approach and more. To focus in on one paradigm (such as storytelling) is a bit of disservice to something as broad as TTRPGs can be.
18,850 views