N
So if the Theia hypothesis is correct, the solar system used to have 10 planets , yes?
18,728,020 views
D
Replying to
@nameshiv
Hi, I did a PhD in planetary sciences. The early solar system was filled with 100s of protoplanets and planetesimals. These either collided with one another or were ejected from the solar system. The Theia hypothesis refers to the specific collision that would have formed the Earth-moon system.
12,900 views
D
Replying to
@doctorallisona
At the time of the event, it is possible there would have still been a lot of other protoplanets flying around - so definitely more than 10 planets. Plus, there’s the ‘Nice’ model, which theorised a massive shift in positions of planets and likely more gravitational ejections a bit later.
12,900 views
D
Replying to
@doctorallisona
By the way, I while I will say Pluto doesn’t count as a planet (we’d have to count 20 more at least), that doesn’t mean there aren’t 9 or 10 or more planets in the solar system. It’s possible there’s a few hiding way beyond Neptune’s orbit - there’s even been some ‘evidence’ of them found already.
12,900 views
K
Replying to
@doctorallisona
Ooh, an expert! What do you think of the theories about "planet 9" being a micro black hole on the edge of our system?
12,900 views
D
Replying to
@kelson
I’m afraid it’s unlikely! Black holes are generally created via massive stellar collapse, therefore have mass greater than our own sun - the gravitational effects would be extreme, we definitely would have noticed!
12,900 views
K
Replying to
@doctorallisona
Yep, for stellar collapse class, that makes sense! I think it latched on to the crack theory of "dark matter is actually ancient black holes", which itself is kinda crazy. Not as crazy as the new "there is no dark matter/energy" theories, but it's fun to think about.
12,900 views
D
Replying to
@kelson
I expect as well that ancient micro or planetary mass black holes would have probably dissipated by now due to hawking radiation.
12,900 views
Replies
No replies yet.