A
Audreyii
@audreyii
Imported Bluesky account. Main topic: general. Original handle: audreyii.bsky.social.
0 Following
0 Followers
A
Replying to
@mrpothead
There is a real chance that no one can replicate what Trump has done, and when he's gone it will be like GWB where everyone pretends like it didn't happen. But I was more confident of that before the techbros started using him as a puppet. We're about to trial by fire their ability to shape reality.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@mrpothead
I don't *disagree*, but it's impossible to ignore that there were three consecutive elections against the same person, all candidates chasing the same coalitions, and, well... one of these things is not like the other. And the consequences have been unspeakable.
29,350 views
A
A
Replying to
@ballparkfranks7
There's also the elephant in the room that none of us really want to focus on, because it's *so* disheartening. Maybe it wasn't the message OR the medium. Maybe Kamala ran as perfect a campaign as she could and eked out every vote it was possible to win. Maybe America just will not elect a woman.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@ballparkfranks7
I mean, I'm happy to be part of a coalition! Lots of different perspectives are great for everyone! Frustrating as fuck when every coalition thinks of themselves "the base" (when if there's a "base" at all it's Black women), but I'd take it over cultish groupthink any day. But it's harder to win.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@ballparkfranks7
Agreed. Can't hurt, at least. But we also have to adjust for the fact that FOX News isn't even the main purveyor of propaganda anymore. Their audience stayed stable in their voting patterns this election, IIRC. We've got to crack the Gen Z infobubble and whatever the fuck is going on w/Gen X.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@ballparkfranks7
And it's not as easy as just duplicating what MAGA has done, because the Democratic party is a coalition, while the GOP is a homogenous white nationalist party w/a handful of "pick me" hangers on that think the leopards won't eat their faces. Coalition parties are inherently hostile to groupthink.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@audreyii
And that uphill climb has become a sheer rockface with Elon in charge of Twitter, Bezos choking the Post, China farming TikTok - and that's only the stuff we know about. Lord knows what Thiel's up to. We keep bailing out a sinking boat and complaining about the size of the bucket. It sucks.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@ballparkfranks7
Yup. Which kind of brings me back to my original original point: If we can't get into that choose-your-own-reality smartphone bubble, then it doesn't matter if we've got the perfect message, because it doesn't make it through the medium. We have to solve for that first, god help us.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@ballparkfranks7
Dems should have been hammering all admin, no question. I think it was a combo of a) Biden not being that sort of politician (sigh), and b) 2024 info enviro being actively hostile. How do you get railroad strikes viral on a TikTok algorithm curated to tradwife content? I'm not sure anyone knows yet.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@absolutereality
That's very much what I want to know too. It also has to be compared against the coalition fracture. 18-29yo MI voters moved 13 points right of their 2020 counterparts. Vibes tell me people born between 95-06 don't care *that* much about the Cheneys. But I could be wrong!
29,350 views
A
A
Replying to
@ballparkfranks7
I think how the message came across is the real culprit here, because "it's getting better but here's our plans to fill the gaps" got filtered through feed algorithms until it became pure vibes. "Eggs cost $4.82 and now cost $3.37, but it doesn't feel* like it" is a Truthiness bubble to break.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@absolutereality
Ooh, thank you. Exactly the kind of stuff I was looking for. I wonder how this would compare against the different environments in 2020 vs 2024? Sports metaphors aren't ideal, but if Liz gained 10 yards with centrists, except Kamala was 15 yards further back from her end zone than Biden had been.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@bryceyoungquist
ahh, my mistake, I thought we were having a discussion about realistic strategy adjustment for future success. Didn't recognize the cues earlier that you were looking for a chorus of accepting your vibes as fact. I left X because I was sick of sophistry from bad faith actors. Blocking now.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@bryceyoungquist
yeah, that's not a terminally online vibes take at all, actual op
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@ballparkfranks7
The alternative is to say Biden *didn't* deliver the best post-pandemic economy in the world? I'd be interested in polling that says "Good things have happened but there's a long way to go" should have been ditched for "We've been in charge for 4 years & everything is worse than ever, vote for us."
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@bryceyoungquist
Here's my vibes take, tbh: in the first week after Biden dropped out, Harris sat w/the Uncommitted group in MI and had a productive convo. 3 hours later the same people interrupted her rally calling her Killer Kamala. She concluded these were not reliable votes & the campaign should focus elsewhere.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@bryceyoungquist
I have seen no evidence that the Dem Party's platform was "shut the fuck up." I saw consistent call for policies that made a real life difference. I also saw evidence of terminally-online people on social media saying stupid shit to drive up engagement provided to curated algorithmic feeds.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@bryceyoungquist
I'm not intending to dunk on you. If there's exit interviews/polling to prove all this then I will sing a different tune. But we will keep chasing our tails forever if we aren't sure we're solving for the right problems.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@bryceyoungquist
Is there also evidence Liz didn't make a difference, though? I mean, vibes seem to say so. But where's the polling? I always took Harris's goal to be that Liz would staunch the bleeding to eke out an extra point or two. Do we have proof the GOP vote wouldn't have been even worse without her?
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@contrasci
I'd've loved to have GA and NC, but if we're talking cold hard facts, what matters is the Blue Wall. Biden won it in 2020. Harris lost it in 2024. Something (or a series of somethings) changed in those states and that's the ballgame. It's the closest apples-to-apples comparison we're likely to find.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@audreyii
And specifically, how campaigning with Liz broke the coalitions in PA, WI, and MI that won Biden the White House in 2020.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@bryceyoungquist
Where is that evidence? I'm happy to see it and adjust my take. But all I've seen is "Dems didn't turn out like we hoped, and also Kamala campaigned with Liz Cheney." That's only correlative with no proof one caused the other.
29,350 views
A
Replying to
@downtownkitty
On the subject, I've noticed that OPs tend to say Kamala lost the base because of whatever the OP's pet issue is. What I haven't seen is evidence that traditional Dems like Black men in PA and 18-24yos in MI shifted toward Trump because of Liz Cheney.
29,350 views