R
Roybennett
@roybennett
Imported Bluesky account. Main topic: general. Original handle: roybennett.bsky.social.
0 Following
0 Followers
R
Replying to
@frankieboy1964
I wouldn`t bet on that, there are always those with money in society in the background manoeuvring to get thier way, they soon chopped Humza down and dragged the party back towards the right when he looked to be gaining ground going to the left..
16,750 views
R
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
I have faith in the young, my son is at uni, very politically engaged, his feed back is encouraging, its just a matter of ensuring they get control of at least one party or it will be very messy and a long haul, at the moment its SNP, he tells me if that door closes it will get very messy indeed
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
If Forbes becomes leader we are done for a decade or more, I wouldn`t blame you for walking. The garden and my veg gives me the peace and perspective I need, too, go well, nice talking to you, even if I was a tad "firm". 🤣
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Forbes is my MSP in a dying conservative area, I understand what we are up against, and also know if they don`t get control now (the next 5-10 yrs) they are finished for several decades, if not permanently, the ground is shifting and they want control to wait things out, before its to late to do so.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Agreed, me too, much as I detest Forbes, I know by walking away I`ll be conceding defeat to those working to drag the party back to the right, its always been a battleground and these attempts to stop it going left come and go, I stay to ensure young progressives win in the long run (10-20 years)
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Me too we can agree to disagree and I share your frustration, ironically its that frustration the wealthy seek to take advantage of though, so we do what we can and try not to be put off, although at times I find myself wanting to punch something, the miners union taught me the value of patience
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Its only managed because voters allow it to be managed, its why the wealthy bought newspapers, now TV` stations, one group seeks entertainment, the other power, v broad generalisations but the principle holds true, unless we choose to change it, we could but need to think in decades not cycles
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
That's reality, plenty of us keep telling other voters, but as my union secretary dad used to tell me beer, football and instant gratification is why workers stay workers and the wealthy stay in control, one thinks in decades/lifetimes, the other weeks, months, rarely more than a year ahead.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Look at Labour, the only young that are tolerated are the ones that follow the agenda of the corporate/wealthy backers, its why they all look and sound identical, its a factory to produce attractive managerial politicians to seduce voters, it works, look at who is thriving and who isn`t.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Once the young progressive talent is driven out, not enough voters will back them with sufficient funds, they will have zero resources and will just disappear into the void, Corbyn was an example. Voters never think like the wealthy, its why they are the "working class" Kier Hardie understood this.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
If they go, once the wealthy get control, they will anoint Forbes in his place, that campaign started a decade ago, unlike voters the wealthy are patient and think in decades not election cycles, the young talent that doesn`t comply will be driven out and yet another party will be controlled.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Its what destroyed Corbyn, with 600k+ members he didn`t need wealthy backers, and could be truly progressive, its why the English establishment destroyed him, a party not controlled by the wealthy, they weren`t having that, and voters promptly fell for it.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Its the dropping membership numbers that are fueling the rise of Swinney/Forbes, and no I don`t like them, but as the income falls the business sector gains ground as the only backer left, and we all know where that ends, hence my cynicism toward many voters, they are often thier own worst enemy.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Well at least you give something, huge numbers don`t, its why I`m cynical toward voters, they say they want change but won`t invest whats needed long term to fight the deep pockets of the wealthy, its why the SNP won`t do corporate backers but I suspect that may have to, if they are to survive sadly
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
The SNP doesn`t "need" voters, it exists to serve those voters who want particular views to be represented, if not enough of the voters are willing to pay for such a party it dies. Its why the wealthy pay for buy parties, they invest in the long term to get what they want, they know how it works
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Do you financially support any of the political parties you vote for ? or do you expect all the work that goes in to give you a choice to be done for nothing ? genuinely asking, if not, how do you expect them to exist ? I`m genuinely asking.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
It has changed, its gone back to the ground which supported it financially, progressives want a party that supports them, but they wouldn`t pay for it. No party runs on fresh air, it goes where the money is, it has to, those who pay the bills get to call the policy, its not rocket science
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Don`t vote for them then, just don`t complain when the only parties you can choose from are the big 3 that the wealthy own. Why should I pay for you to have a choice ? Pay for your own choice, but you don`t want to do that do you ? You are happy others are paying so you can have a "free" choice.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Do you mean you don`t like answering difficult questions and that gives you a good excuse to 1 Not vote for the SNP 2 Blame me for (1) 3 Feel better about you choice because of (2) 4 So then also blame me for the SNP disappearing, not the responsibility of those who voted them out ?
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
I`m not entitled to your vote, or angry, I note when SNP supporters point out the consequences of not voting for the SNP we are accused of "being angry" maybe we touch to many nerves and aren`t popular because of that, truth is often painful, the SNP always being around to vote for isn`t guaranteed
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Greens actively undermine the SNP reducing thier support, Alba can`t get elected and face a much bigger climb now the Salmond has tragically passed on, who will fund them now is anybody`s guess. I`m not even sure they will be able to finance themselves any further, voters don`t fund Scottish parties
16,750 views
R
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Name them, they`re not electable and have little to no funding or govt experience. "Most folk" wheres your real data to support that claim I`m not "blaming" you, pointing out the consequences of the choices being made isn`t "blame" its called placing responsibility and accountability where it lays
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Other parties ? name one that has managed to fund itself, is credible and got elected, they don`t exist.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Its your right to not vote for the only independence party there is, that`s up to you, good luck doing something about it on your own because like all other anti native Scottish party opposition voters its easier to pull others down than build anything to replace us. Have a great day.
16,750 views
R
Replying to
@rantinscot
Fine. I look forward to them replicating the hundreds of millions of pounds the SNP invested, the entire lives of those who laid the groundwork, etc, etc which we both know isn`t going to happen, just looking at the utter inability of non SNP voters to even raise .10p a week for indy shows you that.
16,750 views