J
I've never considered TTRPGs to be about storytelling. At least in my mind, that suggests something way more deliberate than the fucking around, finding out thing happening at our table. We're following the characters, seeing what happens and riffing off of that. There's no aim to "tell a story".
21,851,530 views
J
Replying to
@johannohr
Perhaps I'm misunderstanding this, but to me, playing these games are as much storytelling as my everyday life is. I'm just doing stuff until I'm not, it's not curated for some audience.
18,850 views
R
Replying to
@johannohr
I sound like a broken clock on this topic but it's overdue for TTRPG enthusiasts, especially who want to comment on the Hobby, to understand there are various, often contradicting, forms of TTRPG.
18,850 views
R
Replying to
@rolistespod
OSR: rules lite f' around & find out. Trad/simu: rules heavy f' around & find out. OC/trad: GM-curated storytelling. PbtA/story: rules-curated storytelling.
18,850 views
P
Replying to
@rolistespod
This also becomes a horrible mess when someone doesn't like a label and uses something else. But hey, I'm a metal listener, I'm used to weird sub-genres.
18,850 views
R
Replying to
@panoptikontraba
Labels are useful IMO but people keep picturing/discussing as if they are or should be waterproof drawers. I find they're more like landmarks. You're more or less close to them and their meaning changes based on context.
18,850 views
R
Replying to
@rolistespod
Speaking to someone abroad. Them: Do you live near the Tower of London? Me: Yes quite close. Speaking to someone coming to my place. Them: Do you live near the Tower of London. Me: It's a 50min walk away. You could eventually cycle from there but you better take a bus and get off at REDACTED.
18,850 views
P
Replying to
@rolistespod
Yeah, but it's a bit more messy when you ask if this is like OSR and someone becomes defensive and say no, this is sabrepunk, but when you open the book it is indeed very OSR-y. The taxonomy breaks down!
18,850 views
R
Replying to
@panoptikontraba
Taxonomy and semantics are overrated, especially in TTRPG where there's close to no consensus or academic lexicon. People should be less defensive and just talk. Evergreen advice for TTRPG: "Just talk about it."
18,850 views
R
Replying to
@rolistespod
Fully agree. The fuzzyness of terminology is also exacerbated by the extremely varied way that people play the same set of rules from table to table.
18,850 views
R
Replying to
@reluctantaxe
I wouldn't mind if semantics in the spirit of finding common grounds and supporting communication but it so often brought up as "NO, you use this word wrong. NO this is not X or Y".
18,850 views
Replies
R
Replying to
@rolistespod
I feel it is impossible to find general semantics, particularly around my preference of "story" games. The name, incorrectly, devalues that you can have good stories in other types of games and I understand why people get defensive. I don't see a word to describe these games that wouldn't though
18,850 views